Stories
Slash Boxes
Comments
Search

News for nerds, stuff that matters

Slashdot Log In

Log In

Create Account  |  Retrieve Password

Ashes of Doohan Sent Into Space

Posted by CmdrTaco on Sun Apr 29, 2007 08:13 AM
from the no-original-jokes-left dept.
Sci-Fi
Stephen Samuel writes "The CBC is reporting that Star Trek actor James Doohan ("Scotty") achieved his hopes of having his ashes launched into space when a package containing some of his ashes, ashes of Mercury astronaut Gordon Cooper and about 200 other people were carried into sub-orbital space by a 6 meter (20') rocket. The rocket was launched by UP Aerospace from "Spaceport America", a commercial spaceport being developed in the southern New Mexico desert."
+ -
story

Related Stories

[+] Science: Remains of James Doohan Lost in New Mexico 220 comments
caffiend666 writes "According to a Space.com news article the cremated remains of 200 people were lost in the mountains after their trip to space. 'The search for the UP Aerospace payload of experiments and the cremated remains of some 200 people — including "Scotty" of Star Trek fame, as well as pioneeering NASA Mercury astronaut, Gordon Cooper — continues within rugged New Mexico mountain landscape.' Is it just me, or does it seem appropriate that they lost the landing party? Here's to a safe recovery!"
[+] Science: Scotty Scooped Up 90 comments
mmarlett writes "Scotty has been found. 'The ashes of late Star Trek actor James Doohan have been found in mountains in the US state of New Mexico, where they landed after a brief flight in space.' And pretty much where they thought they put them, too."
This discussion has been archived. No new comments can be posted.
The Fine Print: The following comments are owned by whoever posted them. We are not responsible for them in any way.

Ashes of Doohan Sent Into Space 50 Comments More /

 Full
 Abbreviated
 Hidden
More
Loading... please wait.
  • So "beam me up, Scotty" is now going to translate to "kicking the bucket", eh.

  • Congrats, Scotty! (Score:5, Informative)

    by Anonymous Coward on Sunday April 29 2007, @08:20AM (#18918169)
    You made it into space. If only briefly.

    >>the rocket soon parachuted back to Earth

    "Aye, Cap'n, I cannough change the lews of physics"

    Interestingly, Mr. Doohan was a huge fan of steam locomotives, far away from the high tech of Star Trek, donating his time to a museum, and acting as a locomotive engineer (ok, "driver" to some of you).

    tph

    • ...a locomotive engineer (ok, "driver" to some of you)

      Take a break driver eight...

      • Wow, I'm sure that if he was alive, he would discount you as the angry and ineffectual waste of space that you are.
      • What is it about well-loved public figures that brings out the snotty, jealous little gits like you?

        Jimmy Doohan accomplished far more than you ever will. He inspired two generations of engineers and scientists. What have you ever achieved?

        -jcr

      • He was also part of the Normandy Invasion in World War 2. He lost a finger in the war. He doesn't need to rest on his acting skills, most people already regard him as a true hero.

  • NASA (Score:5, Insightful)

    by DuncanE (35734) * on Sunday April 29 2007, @08:23AM (#18918183) Homepage
    Hmmmm... I would of thought some of the peeps at NASA could of thought of a more individual gesture than that. I realise he's not a REAL spaceman, but surely everyone at the big N A S A can tie a bit of their personal motivation back to good old Scottie....

    Beam me up.

    • Re:NASA (Score:4, Interesting)

      by tinkertim (918832) * on Sunday April 29 2007, @09:22AM (#18918481) Homepage

      Hmmmm... I would of thought some of the peeps at NASA could of thought of a more individual gesture than that. I realise he's not a REAL spaceman, but surely everyone at the big N A S A can tie a bit of their personal motivation back to good old Scottie....

      Discovery channel (last year) did a special on Vitamin Trek, how ST changed and helped shaped technology. If you look at the Ion Propulsion lab at NASA, it looks quite a bit like the engine room of the NCC 1701.

      He was of course an actor, but his acting was geek inspiring. I would have thought catapulting him to the sun or on a course likely to hit one of the gas giants would have been more fitting. I guess that costs money though :)

      So in memorium I'd just like to say :

      Up your shaft.

      (no, not flame bait, he said that on the Excelsior when the turbo lift talked to him)
    • They do, for people they care about.

      Eugene Shoemaker wound up with some of his ashes on the Lunar Prospector spacecraft, which eventually flown into the moon. He was the guy who co-discovered Comet Shoemaker-Levy 9, which eventually smacked into Jupiter.

      See: Lunar spacecraft carries ashes, special tribute to Shoemaker [nasa.gov]

      • Eugene Shoemaker wound up with some of his ashes on the Lunar Prospector spacecraft, which eventually flown into the moon. He was the guy who co-discovered Comet Shoemaker-Levy 9, which eventually smacked into Jupiter.

        Likewise, ashes of Clyde Tombaugh [wikipedia.org], the discoverer of Pluto, are being carried by the New Horizons [wikipedia.org] space probe, due to fly past Pluto, the Kuiper Belt and on into the interstellar void...

  • First Spock now Scotty (Score:5, Funny)

    by Zedrick (764028) on Sunday April 29 2007, @08:24AM (#18918197)
    TFA doesn't say, but I presume it's aimed towards (planet) Genesis?

    • Re: (Score:3, Informative)

      by Anonymous Coward
      It is sort of disappointing. Only one ounce of the actor's ashes were aboard the rocket and the rocket only reached sub-orbital space (good for a rocket but not so cool for an individual's ashes being flown into space). Worse, it seems that everything came back with the rocket. So, really, what happened is one ounce of Doohan's ashes made a round-trip jaunt to sub-orbital space. They spent maybe a couple minutes there and now all of his ashes are back on Earth.

      There is no chance for a Spock/Genesis sto
      • Maybe we could think all of his ashes are still waiting for the right spaceship to take him into interstellar space. If it did a slingshot around the Sun, it would only be better.

        I am sure he would think it to be worth the wait.

      • Re: (Score:3, Interesting)

        by pclminion (145572)

        Worse, it seems that everything came back with the rocket. So, really, what happened is one ounce of Doohan's ashes made a round-trip jaunt to sub-orbital space. They spent maybe a couple minutes there and now all of his ashes are back on Earth.

        And your point is? We sure as hell HOPE that our astronauts COME BACK from their missions. He travelled high enough to earn a set of civilian Astronaut Wings. And like a real astronaut, he came back when he was done. I'm sure he'd be happy.

  • Sub-orbital space? (Score:4, Interesting)

    by owlstead (636356) on Sunday April 29 2007, @08:34AM (#18918239)
    If you've got a small rocket (6 meters), that has already failed once, it's better to put part of the remains of a person in it than trying to fit a live person into it. So from that point of view I can understand this experiment.

    But to shoot ashes into space, while knowing they will return anyway, and first viewing an unsucccessful launch (ugh), what's the point? Glad it worked this time, having to return a third time, only to do it all over again... that might have been hard for the relatives.

    • Re:Sub-orbital space? (Score:5, Funny)

      by Rogerborg (306625) on Sunday April 29 2007, @10:29AM (#18918859) Homepage
      Sure; if you want to fling corpses way up in the air and then have them land again, just use a trebuchet.
    • Unfortunately it would probably take something the size of a modern Titan rocket to get Scotty's ashes the rocket launch they deserve: Escape velocity from the Sun. Maybe with enough extra velocity to pass the two Voyagers by the 23rd century.

      I don't think anyone was willing to put up the ~$200 million or so for the launch. ;)

      • Maybe with enough extra velocity to pass the two Voyagers by the 23rd century.
        Maybe with enough extra velocity to pass the two V'gers by the 23rd century.

        There, I fixed that for you.

  • Guidbye, Scotty (Score:5, Funny)

    by tverbeek (457094) on Sunday April 29 2007, @08:49AM (#18918323) Homepage
    May your dilithium crystals be fully charged, your matter/anti-matter reaction balanced, your wee bairns well cared for, and the transport to your final shore leave free of malfunctions.

    Energise.

  • Sub-orbital space? (Score:5, Funny)

    by niceone (992278) * on Sunday April 29 2007, @08:52AM (#18918337) Journal
    Is sub-orbital space the not-so-final frontier? Is he boldly almost going?

    • Re: (Score:3, Insightful)

      by FlyByPC (841016)
      The problem is, they didn't have Scotty working on the engines. Had he been available to help, they'd have made orbit for sure -- and then some.

      I'm within a year of finishing up my Engineering Technology degree. I know for a fact that Doohan's "Scotty" had a lot to do with my interest in Engineering, even though I'm not a hardcore Trekkie. (I just think it's a good sci-fi TV show.)
      Here's to a job well done, Mr. Scott -- we miss you.

  • they had trouble with the first launch (Score:5, Funny)

    by Coraon (1080675) on Sunday April 29 2007, @09:18AM (#18918463)
    Ironicly, the best person to fix this rocket would have been scotty.

    • Ironicly, the best person to fix this rocket would have been scotty.
      That's probably why they decided to put him on this launch. Why else do you think that the flight went well?.

    • "...Ironicly, the best person to fix this rocket would have been scotty..."

      I agree.

      It's not well known, but whenever the Saturn V was playing up, NASA always got a hammy old actor in to sort out pogo resonance problems or suchlike. These thespians have hidden depths...

      T&K.

  • Fare thee well, Mr. Doohan (Score:3, Funny)

    by netwiz (33291) on Sunday April 29 2007, @09:31AM (#18918525) Homepage
    Now all that remains is to put a pint of seawater on the moon with the appropriately inscribed air cylinder shipping label.

    /obscure, see if you can get it.
  • When you consider that the atoms that made up his body were most likely created by stellar nuclear synthesis and distributed around the universe by supernova.

    If they shot my toenail clippings into space I wouldn't really feel like I had been there. No matter how many clippings were used.

  • James Doohan WW2 Vet (Score:5, Interesting)

    by rvr (15565) on Sunday April 29 2007, @09:57AM (#18918685) Homepage
    I remember reading a bio of James Doohan when he died. My esteem went up for him greatly when I read that he was a WW2 vet. Born in Vancouver (woohoo!) and led a group of men at Juno beach on D-Day taking a few bullets in the process. The world seemed a little bit colder to me when I heard that he died. Fare thee well James.

    • Re:James Doohan WW2 Vet (Score:5, Informative)

      by FlyingSquidStudios (1031284) on Sunday April 29 2007, @10:37AM (#18918921) Homepage
      Which cost him one of his fingers (and thankfully that's all). He tried to hide it as often as he could, but there are a few episodes of Star Trek where you can see his missing index finger in a shot or two. Also, unknown to most people, he provided the voices of a lot of the supporting and incidental characters in the animated Star Trek show. He always had a talent for voices.

      • He always had a talent for voices.
        His talent for voices extended to his Scottish accent. As the GF post said, He was born in Vancouver [google.com] (that's 200Miles North of Seattle for the geographically impaired).
      • I never knew about the finger - I'm surprised they didn't try and make it part of the character with a backstory to explain it (laddie, have ye ever seen a plasitron beam break its containment field ...) On second thoughts, it would be a poor second to the real truth.
    • One of those bullets would have surely killed him if not for the silver cigarette case he had in his pocket at the time, a gift from his brother before he left for the front. Who said smoking kills?
  • It took a small part of his his ashes up then brought them back down... I bet that wasn't what he was thinking.

  • Craziest pilot in the Canadian Air Forces (Score:3, Interesting)

    by Tteddo (543485) on Sunday April 29 2007, @10:37AM (#18918925) Homepage
    Just read this at Wikipedia: "One of the many legendary stories of his flying years tells of Doohan slaloming a plane -- variously cited as a Hurricane or a jet trainer -- between mountainside telegraph poles to prove it could be done, which earned him a serious reprimand." http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Doohan [wikipedia.org]

  • suborbital (Score:3, Informative)

    by PineGreen (446635) on Sunday April 29 2007, @11:21AM (#18919179) Homepage
    It is suborbital, so the ashes will, eventually, fall back to earth. Their net energy is still negative.

  • Obligatory Scotty Quote (Score:5, Funny)

    by SeaDour (704727) on Sunday April 29 2007, @11:47AM (#18919335) Homepage
    SCOTT (to Waiter): "What in blazes is this?"

    WAITER (confused): "Didn't you order Scotch?"

    SCOTT: "Lad, I was drinking scotch about a hundred years before you were born and I can tell you that whatever this is, it is definitely not scotch."

    DATA (to Waiter): "I believe I may be of some assistance. Captain Scott is unaware of the existence of synthehol."

    SCOTT: "Synthehol?"

    DATA: "Yes. It is an alcohol substitute which is now normally served aboard starships. It simulates the appearance, smell, and taste of alcohol, but the intoxicating effects can be easily dismissed."

    SCOTT: "You're not quite... human are you?"

    DATA: "No, sir. I am an android. My name is Commander Data."

    SCOTT: "Synthetic scotch and synthetic commanders..."

    DATA: "I believe Guinan does keep a limited supply of non-syntheholic products. Perhaps one of them would be to your liking."

    Data bends down and reaches under the bar... then stands up and puts a very old bottle of a green liquid on the bar.

    SCOTT: "What is it?"

    DATA: "It is..." (tries to inspect the label) "It is..." (takes a sniff of it) "...it is green."
  • He's dead, Jim.
  • I was lucky to meet Mr. Doohan at a book signing in Los Angeles 15 years ago. May he rest in peace and I am glad he got his final wish. Mr. Scott is definitely my favorite Star Trek character and thank you so much for acting him out.

    "He called you a tin-plated dictator with delusions of grandeur."
    "So, that's when you hit him?"
    "No, sir, you told us to be restrained." ...
    "He called the Enterprise a pile of garbage and that's when I hit him."
    "You're relieved of duty and confined to quarters until further not
  • to have my ashes shot into the sun.
    Because we all that we are came from the sun and other suns, I feel it would be a genuine continuance of the circle of life to return whence we came. Forget "ashes to ashes", I prefer "atoms to atoms"..

    The sun is the real giver of life.

  • Wow, what are the odds...? (Score:3, Funny)

    by Slur (61510) on Sunday April 29 2007, @05:33PM (#18921785) Homepage Journal
    Scotty and Captain Pike [inthenews.co.uk] launched in the same week!
  • I thought it was a new Harry Potter book!

  • Makes me think (Score:5, Funny)

    by Boyceterous (596732) on Sunday April 29 2007, @08:43PM (#18923025)
    of what I would want done with my ashes. Doohan had a lover for outer space. I want my ashes shot into a woman. If there was any DNA left, I guess they could name the kid "Ashley"
  • Ashes of Doohan: Band name or sci-fi/fantasy series?

    • Re:Great (Score:4, Informative)

      by a_nonamiss (743253) on Sunday April 29 2007, @08:44AM (#18918295)
      Had you read the article, you'd know this was a sub-orbital flight. Nothing left in space.

      From TFA:

      Since it was a suborbital flight, the rocket soon parachuted back to Earth, coming down at the White Sands Missile Range.
      While technically a spaceflight, it was more or less a really high-altitude rocket.
    • Carl Sagan wrote something similar in his novel Contact. Cancer-stricken S.R. Hadden fakes his own death, then launches himself in a small ship away from the solar system. He stays conscious to catch the views as he passes by the gas giants, then enters a deep freeze, hoping to be awakened in a few million years by a passerby alien who can cure his disease.

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective owners. Comments are owned by the Poster. The Rest © 1997-2009 Geeknet, Inc.