2005 Hugo Nominations 171
COBOLgrrl writes " The 2005 Hugo Nominations have been announced. Books up for Best Novel include The Algebraist by Iain M. Banks, Iron Council by China Miéville , Iron Sunrise by Charles Stross, Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell by Susanna Clarke, and River of Gods by Ian McDonald."
Hugo Lowdown. (Score:5, Informative)
Re:Hugo Lowdown. (Score:3, Informative)
Re:Hugo Lowdown. (Score:4, Informative)
Re:Hugo Lowdown. (Score:2, Informative)
Re:Hugo Lowdown - SCI FI, not just books (Score:3, Insightful)
Re:Hugo Lowdown - SCI FI, not just books (Score:2)
That episode was the first time I saw a sci-fi show and didn't think "ehhh, Farscape was much better." Even though one of the main plot devices is essentially ripped off from Farscape, what they've done with it is very different but just as good. And although it's much more understated than Farscape, the show still occasionally delivers a total mindfuck. By the end of Season 1 I had no idea what was going to happen.
Of course, the real test is whether they'll kill off main cha
Re:Hugo Lowdown. (Score:1, Insightful)
And a "Harry Potter" book has won it. A "Harry Potter" film has been nominated for this year.
Peter H
There should be more online awards given........ (Score:4, Insightful)
Re:There should be more online awards given....... (Score:5, Insightful)
And you know how english majors are.
wise words (Score:2, Funny)
Re:There should be more online awards given....... (Score:2, Interesting)
However, remember to extend this logic and not discount the quality of something just because it is popular. It's funny that a sibling post mentions The Da Vinci Code, because as soon as I had finished reading your post, I thought to myself "Someone's gonna say 'yeah like The Da Vinci code!'".
FWIW, I thought that The Da Vinci Code was a good book. Not because I believed that most of presented conspiracies and other 'facts' were true, but because, well, it's a damn good story, pure f
Re:There should be more online awards given....... (Score:4, Insightful)
I haven't yet read The Da Vinci Code, but it might interest you that both Dickens and Shakespeare wrote what amounts to pop culture in their time. They're considered classics because they were both great writers and their works have stood the test of time. But at the time that they wrote, they were both firmly a part of popular culture.
Without having read the 'Code, I'd take a wild guess that it's not destined to become a classic. But that doesn't matter if you enjoy it, nor if millions enjoy it. It is what it is, and after reading what you wrote, I'm actually interested in reading it.
BTW, I'm not the sort of cunt who loves telling people that I've read War And Peace. I look down on those cunts. I'm the sort of cunt that loves telling people I've read Gravity's Rainbow. But then there are the cunts who love to tell people they've read Ulysses, and they tend to look down on cunts like me.
Re:There should be more online awards given....... (Score:2)
Oh yeah? Well, I'm the sort of cunt who likes to tell people that I've read Go, Dog, Go! and Hop on Pop, in the same day no less...
Bim's bent broom breaks (Score:2)
Hooptie
Re:There should be more online awards given....... (Score:2)
You've just put into words what I've been meaning (Score:2)
Re:There should be more online awards given....... (Score:5, Funny)
Re:There should be more online awards given....... (Score:1)
Open online voting would create huge headaches and would be very hard to secure (people could easily vote more than once). If online polls at CNN, MSNBC and other news sites are to be believed, George W. Bush trounced John Kerry in November's elections. The reason most online polls are 90 percent inaccurate is because they're self-selected and do not accurately represent the whole popu
Re:There should be more online awards given....... (Score:1)
Re:There should be more online awards given....... (Score:2)
I dunno. It sounds too much like "The People's Choice Awards."
Re:There should be more online awards given....... (Score:4, Informative)
Compare this with the Nebula, voted and awarded by members of SFWA (Science Fiction and Fantasy Writers of America), which requires proof that you've made paid sales of SF (or F). That's closer to the Oscars, which is nominated and voted on by members of the Academy of Motion Pictures.
What's the point of online awards? It's too easy to rig the voting, or for the utterly unqualified to vote.
Re:There should be more online awards given....... (Score:4, Informative)
Paladin of Souls, by Lois McMaster Bujold (Eos, Oct 2003)
Down and Out in the Magic Kingdom, by Cory Doctorow (Tor, Feb 2003)
Omega, by Jack McDevitt (Ace, Nov 2003)
Cloud Atlas: A Novel, by David Mitchell (Sceptre, Jan 2004)
Perfect Circle, by Sean Stewart (link to Private Edition) (Small Beer Press, Jun 2004)
The Knight, by Gene Wolfe (Tor, Jan 2004)
PALADIN OF SOULS won last year's Hugo, for instance.
SFWA also has a committee whose job is to read "less popular" books that may be great but overlooked and add one such book to the ballot. You don't get that with Hugos. I'm not sure such an added book has ever won, however, but I imagine it might helps sales a bit.
Re:There should be more online awards given....... (Score:2)
Iron Sunrise totally kicked ass. (Score:2)
Scratch Monkey (Score:3, Informative)
And there's more speculative future history by J.R. Mooneyham [jrmooneyham.com].
Re:Iron Sunrise totally kicked ass. (Score:1)
Melville is overrated (Score:5, Insightful)
In my opinion, China Melville is overrated as an author. His Perdido Street Station was the "it" book of 2001, but after I finished reading it, I couldn't help but wonder what the big deal was.
Granted, he has an excellent sense of the phantasmagoric and his worldbuilding skills are certainly impressive, but as an author, he just doesn't have the chops. His characters are almost too angst-ridden to move in a forward direction, and his plots read like a bad slasher flicks.
Take away his word processor and give him a job as a conceptual designer. Everyone will be happier in the long run.
Re:Melville is overrated (Score:2)
Re:Melville is overrated (Score:2)
I thought you were making some gigantic pun about Moby Dick.
Re:Melville is overrated (Score:2)
Ditto for Charles Stross -- _Atrocity Archives_ is an enjoyable read, but _Singularity Sky_ is a third-rate potboiler. It's as if Tom Clancy decided to write sci-fi, yech.
Re:Melville is overrated (Score:2)
First, I don't think you've read enough truly bad sci-fi/fantasy, most of which mieville is leagues better than, no matter what his shortcomings are.
Second, don't you think it's possible for an author to improve? Perdido street station was his second book. If you took away the word processor(/pen) of everyone who couldn't write well, no one would ever get to wri
It's his third book numbnutz (Score:2)
Re:Melville is overrated (Score:2)
I bought both PSS and King Rat at the same time from an Amazon recommendation (which, by and large, are pretty good). I read Perdido first, didn't like it that well, and nearly didn't read King Rat. That would have been
Re:Melville is overrated (Score:2)
Something like the feeling when reading bad manuals about too complex APIs...
It was the emotional effect on this reader, anyway.
Re:Melville is overrated (Score:2)
They really should add a "-1, Stupid" moderation category. *sigh*
Re:Melville is overrated (Score:2)
The first book of his that I read was The Scar (I think because of its Hugo nomination, actually). I absolutely loved it. Fantastic. Then read Perdido Street Station, and it's not quite as good, but still very enjoyable. Then tried King Rat and didn't even finish it - it just did nothing for me.
So based on that (it's reverse chronological order), I'd say he's very much improving himself, and I should really read Iron Council. But I haven't yet, for one thing because I've read some reviews that weren't that
Re:Melville is overrated (Score:2)
Re:Melville is overrated (Score:2)
China Miéville is his real name. Interview: [strangehorizons.com] The name, he says, is a result of having hippie parents.
At last, Iain M Banks gets a bit of recognition (Score:4, Interesting)
Most of his SciFi books are based on 'The Culture' which is basically the human race in a few thousand years. VCool tech. and Uber-Cool Space Ship names ('Meat Fucker') is the nick-name other ships have given to one particular ship, 'cause it likes to read the minds of humans.
If you're going to read any of his books, read 'The Player of Games'. Amazing read. (Tiny spoiler...) There is a bit where the lead finds out about a very dark side to the race who he is 'Playing' with. From that point, he stops talking. Then only when he has taken apart the next few players does he speak. Iain M Banks is truely a very great under-appreciated author. READ HIM.
Re:At last, Iain M Banks gets a bit of recognition (Score:1, Interesting)
Re:At last, Iain M Banks gets a bit of recognition (Score:5, Interesting)
I haven't read the novel in question, but if his Culture books are any indication of this novel's quality, it will be just as amazing and worthy of the Hugo.
--
Want a free iPod? [freeipods.com]
Or try a free Nintendo DS, GC, PS2, Xbox. [freegamingsystems.com] (you only need 4 referrals)
Wired article as proof [wired.com]
Re:At last, Iain M Banks gets a bit of recognition (Score:4, Informative)
I don't think this is Bank's fault... for quite a few reasons actually. Firstly, writing someone significantly smarter than you is close to impossible.
He also postulates in one of his books that all intelligence past a certain level is equivalent with only differences in speed and capacity (a kind of Turing principle for sentience), which doesn't seem unreasonable. But his AIs should be at that level, whereas I often felt that they didn't have the situational mastery that you might expect - they sometimes completely understand a situation before it's even begun, but they can also act on crazy impulses and be singleminded. I would expect they would always be on perfect form.
Finally, he says that AIs are coloured by the people who create them... and the people of the Culture are pretty immature. Perhaps he's saying something about them.
Anyway, I understand that The Algebraist isn't a Culture novel, so perhaps Banks will get his Hugo since he doesn't have to write in the minefield that is super-intelligences.
Re:At last, Iain M Banks gets a bit of recognition (Score:2)
Whilst the Algebraist is still very good, and would be a worthy Hugo winner, my feeling is that Banks may be reaching the end of his personal well of good fiction. If you're a Banks fan then I'd strongly recommend reading his first non-fiction work "Raw Spirit", which is, loosly, about Malt Whisky. It probably helps that I'm a malt fan myself and live in Scotland
Re:At last, Iain M Banks gets a bit of recognition (Score:4, Interesting)
Some notes/corrections to your post.
The Culture is NOT the human race. The Humanoids in the Culture are from across this Galaxy, but if they've made contact with Humanity on Earth is alluded to in a post-scrip to one of the early Culture novels. Basicly Humanoids that can inter-breed are widespread across the Galaxy, a reason for this is alcohol, mentioned while a character was drunk and in jest.
There are many species in Culture, a large percentage of them are humanoid with various differences, but mostly like us.
AI have been given full rights in Culture and it's late shards, on a sliding scale of rights vs. sentience.
Player of Games is a good start for the setting, Extension I liked the least.
Re:At last, Iain M Banks gets a bit of recognition (Score:3, Interesting)
China Mieville - An excellent job of world building. Great wordsmith. Very screwed-up stuff, but qui
Re:At last, Iain M Banks gets a bit of recognition (Score:2)
You say that as if it were a bad thing.
Re:At last, Iain M Banks gets a bit of recognition (Score:2)
Re:At last, Iain M Banks gets a bit of recognition (Score:3, Interesting)
Even more than most Banks, it's not always an easy read, but it's compulsive and ultimately very rewarding.
Time to Place orders on Amazon.com (Score:5, Insightful)
From last summer's reading list
Finished:
Perdido Street Station - China Melville
Neverwhere - Neil Gaiman
The Golden Age - John C. Wright
Pattern Recognition - William Gibson
Cryptonomicon - Neal Stephenson
Manifold Series - Stephen Baxtor
Currently Reading:
King Rat - Neil Gaiman
Still to Go:
Oryx and Crake - Margaret Atwood
Some other Authors I follow
David Bin, Ben Bova, Larry Niven, Jerry Pournelle, Frederik Pohl.
I find the quality of my reading much better on average following Slashdot suggestions rather than randomly picking books by title and pretty covers at Barnes & Noble.
Didn't quite care for Pattern Recognition, so just one clunker for me -- maybe I just didn't get it, I wanted more of a well defined plot.
Taking inordinate pride in making through all 1130 pages of Cyrptonomicon, but after you make it past the first 300 pages you'll find yourself screaming through it.
Re:Time to Place orders on Amazon.com (Score:3, Funny)
You slut!
Re: Time to Place orders on Amazon.com (Score:1)
Re: Time to Place orders on Amazon.com (Score:2)
Re:Time to Place orders on Amazon.com (Score:2)
Re:Time to Place orders on Amazon.com (Score:2)
David Brin is another so-so writer, in my opinion -- not usually bad, but never really making it to great. Hey, we can't all be the best thing since sliced bread, and there's a place for "pretty good". He's usually good for ideas, but with
Re:Time to Place orders on Amazon.com (Score:2)
While it is an excellent!!!! story the ending is just bad. Until she comes out with the sequal, to answer a bunch of questions that Oryx and Crake asks, advoid it unless you like unfinsihed stories.
Re:Time to Place orders on Amazon.com (Score:2, Interesting)
Re:Time to Place orders on Amazon.com (Score:2)
Dog-Eared (Score:2)
Computer Shopper. (Score:2)
--grendel drago
Totally unsolicted review (Score:4, Interesting)
One book that is not mentioned here that I highly recommend is Dan Simmons' Ilium [amazon.com]. This was a 12-hour read - problem was, it was 12 straight hours because I couldn't put the damn thing down!!
Ilium (Score:2)
Re:Totally unsolicted review (Score:2)
What worries me is that it'll turn out to be another "Hyperion" or even "Endymion", where he spins a fantastic, well-thought-out world full of complex, compelling characters, and then follows up with a sequel that has none of the magic and wraps everything up poorly ("void that binds"? WTF?). "Ilium" was awesome but I have no idea how he'll tie everything together coherently.
Re:Totally unsolicted review (Score:2)
"Paper: The medium of the future"
"Cost-efficient publishing with paper"
"Books that don't need to be plugged in"
etc.
Re:Totally unsolicted review (Score:2)
A Hugo First: The British Invasion (Score:5, Interesting)
This just reinforces my impression that American SF is stagnant while all the real action these days is taking place across the pond. Great stuff, and I hope American authors take this as a kick in the pants to stop rehashing the same old material and start showing a little imagination.
Re:A Hugo First: The British Invasion (Score:4, Funny)
we have representatives from Scotland, England, and Ireland.
All of those in one entrant: Ian McDonald. From his web site:
born in 1960 in Manchester, England by an Irish mother and a Scottish father. He moved with his family to Northern Ireland
Hearts, Hand and Voices (his second novel?) was one of my favourite sci-fi novels.
Re:A Hugo First: The British Invasion (Score:4, Insightful)
I'm not going to name names but, apropos of nothing, I miss the days when Weber was a type of carburettor, not an anti-insomnia treatment.
Compare with the 'Culture' novels; they might all be set in the same universe, but they can stand on their own and are all very different novels.
And how about the politics? If US writers are to be believed the only choice is between high-frontier Libertidiotanism or tree-hugging eco-bleeding-heartedness. Read some Iain Banks or Ken MacLeod and you'll see more political variety than just about all US science fiction put together.
It's a real shame, because US science fiction used to be the best in the world.
Re:A Hugo First: The British Invasion (Score:2)
Re:A Hugo First: The British Invasion (Score:3, Informative)
I don't really think American SF is stagnant; there are several brilliant writers here (John C. Wright comes to mind), just because in one year it's non-US nominees doesn't necessarily mean anything. And I think a lot of the best work coming out of the US is in short stories and novellas; check out the year's best collections edited by Hartwell if you don't believe me.
Re:A Hugo First: The British Invasion (Score:2)
And as an American SF writer, I'd like to point out that these generalities are incorrect or in bad taste. Science fiction is a case of small number statistics. If you think all "American" science fiction is bad, but like some of the British stuff, you've probably not read widely enough. There are differences in flavor, but it isn't a case of "good" vs. "bad."
I'll give my fellow British writers credit for spearheading the renaissance
Re:A Hugo First: The British Invasion (Score:3, Interesting)
And I like many of the newer Brit writers, but I would not call American Sf in the "doldrums."
Re:A Hugo First: The British Invasion (Score:3, Informative)
Incidentally, anybody else think that the convention venue [worldcon.org.uk] looks like a low-budget Sydney Opera House?
Re:A Hugo First: The British Invasion (Score:2, Interesting)
The problem with American SF is that it has become too commercialized. Example? Easy one. I give you "Star Trek" under Roddenberry. And then Star Trek under Berman.
The publishers have the whip hand. This has gone back at least a double decade. If trilogy
Re:A Hugo First: The British Invasion (Score:2)
Re:A Hugo First: The British Invasion (Score:2)
I wish I knew WTF was taking him so long to get "A Feast of Crows" out already!
Alegbraist not his best work (Score:3, Interesting)
I found myself questioning the space opera characters very early on. I mean a baddie with diamond teeth and red eyes! I mean really! Surely an author of his calibre can make a villain despicable beyond the all too familar plot abbreviations.
I'm disappointed that Richard Morgan didn't get a mention for Market Forces.
Market Forces, The Algebraist and others (Score:2)
That said, while I like Morgan a lot, I think he really cripples himself in these sorts of awards with his sex scenes. (Haven't read MF yet- maybe he's stopped) To a 16-year-old boy, these are probably the coolest. To me, pushing 40, they're an embarrassment. "Gee, 2 pages of poorly written porn. Flip." I suspect I'm not exactly alone here. I always loved the way Zelanzy handled sex scenes- a bit of a leadup, then
Re:Market Forces, The Algebraist and others (Score:2)
MF is much better than Altered Carbon and Broken Angels in terms of the sex scenes, but he loses points for having the protagonist wind up reading Altered Carbon at one point.
Market Forces wasn't bad, but I thought it broke down towards the end.
Re:Market Forces, The Algebraist and others (Score:2)
When will they start selling in the US? (Score:1, Interesting)
I've been waiting to get my hands on that book for a long time.
Predictions, etc. (Score:5, Interesting)
I also predict that the winner won't be American. Yeah, this is the first year that no American was nominated for best novel. Note that the Hugo is voted on by Worldcon members, and Worldcon is in Scotland this year. So a substantial portion of the voters will be able to travel to Scotland for the con, and I believe several of these nominees are more well-known in the UK. They're all really good--don't get me wrong--but location is probably a factor in this list.
Incidentally, here's a really good round-up of the best SF/Fantasy novels published last year: http://groups-beta.google.com/group/rec.arts.sf.wr itten/msg/4ab6c83b0b234305 [google.com]
Re:Predictions, etc. (Score:2, Insightful)
Err, no. I don't think the Worldcon's location has anything to do with it. Most Worldcon members live in the US even in years when the Worldcon isn't being held there. I
No Surprises (Score:1)
Re:No Surprises (Score:2)
sci-fi (Score:2)
Re:sci-fi (Score:1)
Re:sci-fi (Score:2)
I saw Iain recently at Stirling University doing a reading and question/answer session. Among other things he was quite strong on The Bridge being his best novel overall, and Use of Weapons his best SF. Also said the The Algebraist was his first book produced without the aid of his long-term editor and in retrospect his thought it was a bit over-long, although I can't
Re:sci-fi (Score:2)
Inversions marked the time when I pretty much stopped reading Sci-fi: I'm not sure why, I guess I just got bored. Having just seen the travesty the Sci-Fi channel made out of Earthsea and being reminded of how much I loved Sci-fi/fantasy *books*, I'm off to Amazon.
Re:sci-fi (Score:2)
The only other author I can think of off the top of my head who can avoid the "Sci-Fi stigma" by writing about alternative realities is Ki
MEANINGLESS Award (Score:1)
Actually it would be the 2004 Hugo nominations ... (Score:3, Informative)
Downloadable? (Score:2)
science fiction artwork (Score:2, Informative)
I was able to find nice galleries online for nominees John Picacio [johnpicacio.com], Fred Gambino [alisoneldred.com], Bob Eggleton [das-brisingamen.de], and Donato Giancola [donatoart.com].
River of Gods (Score:2, Insightful)
Re:River of Gods (Score:2)
Re:River of Gods (Score:2)
Re:River of Gods (Score:2)
(Yes, Canada is in both North America and the Co
British bias not unexpected... (Score:2, Interesting)
Hugo's not just books... (Score:2)
In the "Best Dramatic Presentation - Short Form" (TV) category, the nominations were the pilot of Lost, two Angel episodes, as well as ones from Battlestar Galactica & StarGate SG-1. The SG-1 episode was the two parter "Heroes", which I for one loved immensely. The BSG nomination was for their first episode, "33". Definitely good, but I'm saddened at the lack of love for the BSG miniseries.
--LordPixie
My Iron Council Review (Score:2)