Catch up on stories from the past week (and beyond) at the Slashdot story archive

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×
Technology

Wiring A New House? 730

jbp123 asks: "I'm building a new house. Once the electrician has run the phone lines I want to run cat5e ethernet cable. I figure two drops to each of the 6 rooms with phone lines. I've never done this but my plan is to run the ethenet cable through the same path that the phone lines follow. I'll use up the rest of the 1000 foot spool by running a third cable to a few of the rooms. Ethernet cable is cheap. I found solid cat5e 1000 foot spools for $60 delivered so the decision to run cat5e cable is a no brainer. The question is should I run fiber? I really don't know how much the cable costs since I don't know what cable to use. It is much easier to run cable before the drywall goes in so I want to make an informed decision now. Ten years from now will I need/want fiber?"
This discussion has been archived. No new comments can be posted.

Wiring A New House?

Comments Filter:
  • by jarodss ( 243400 ) <mikedupuis79&hotmail,com> on Sunday December 09, 2001 @02:59PM (#2678894) Homepage
    Not like this hasn't popped up on slash a few times before, but why only phone, cat5 and fiber?

    What about running Svideo and RCA to everyroom or an extra drop of cat5 to run sound on?

    And as far as running the cat5 parallel to the phone, if your building the house why not set your cables into conduits, that way you can upgrade to whatever cabling you need in ten years.
    • I'd be surprised if the Svideo or RCA cable can handle any decent level of quality on a long run. RJ6 (coax) would be a better choice there, it's easy to tap and can go long distances.

      There is technology coming down the pike (some available today) that will allow digital video to run over Cat5E cable.
      • by isorox ( 205688 ) on Sunday December 09, 2001 @03:23PM (#2679018) Homepage Journal
        We have 20m runs of svideo at the uni tv station no problem. If you're more interested in length though we've done 100+m runs of high quality microphone cable (for video, £1.40 a metre), and 5-m+ runs of cheap (15p/metre) common tv cable with a couple of bnc or composite ends stuck on.

        We have a 300m rj6 crap quality cable with 2 20db boosters and a high output on the VTR at the start and another booster at the end (before a proper industry booster and splitter with another 200m run from there).

        If you need more then a 50m (150 foot) single run in your new house I'm envious.

        However its all very well dropping in whatever cables you need, think about how you are going to use them - do you really want them all arriving in your basement? Drop a lot more cable down to your living room, just in case.

        Might be worthwhile sticking some cheap speaker wire or 2 core mains flex down there too - if you need a signal.

        And finaly, whatever you come up with, double it. A video signal to each room is fine, until you want a tv in there, and a camera.
    • by Colin ( 1746 ) on Sunday December 09, 2001 @03:15PM (#2678970)
      What about running Svideo and RCA to everyroom or an extra drop of cat5 to run sound on?

      There are various (cheapish - under $100) ways of running video over Cat5. Personally, I've got Cat5 and audio cables into rooms, and run everything over that.

      However, 2 per room is not enough. There are a number of reasons for this:

      • They're never where you want them. You'll always want to move stuff around, and cables draped across the floor doesn't look good.
      • Once you've got the cables in, you'll see more uses. For example, telephone, TV, Audio for hifi, remote control for hifi, remote control for lighting, PC network - all possibly in one room.
      • When building, it's cheap. It's much easier to put these cables in before the drywall goes up. Trying to fish them through afterwards is hard work. BTDT

      Don't bother with fibre. It's not going to get used. People have been saying "fibre is the next big thing" for 5 years now - and cable just keeps catching up. Video over Cat5 is cheap - so, instead of piping cable round the house, put all the set top boxes in one location, and remote control them. 100Mb Ethernet is very cheap - VHS video quality needs about 3 Mb/sec, so you can stream that across existing networks. Hi definition uncompressed video is more than 100Mb/sec - but 1Gb/sec over copper is on the horizon.

      • Same thing with power outlets. There used to never be enough power outlets in rooms. Then that changed over the past few decades. :)

        Remote control for lighting should be done with X-10 enabled equipment. It's a simple, low speed network, but it doesn't need to be fast. Most X-10 devices just need to turn on or off. Plus it runs over the existing power lines, so that will save a lot of money not having to run all those cables to turn on each light.

        HDTV at its max resolution, uncompressed, requires 1.2Gbps. Heehee. Bandwidth! :)
    • OT: Use plenum (Score:5, Informative)

      by mosch ( 204 ) on Sunday December 09, 2001 @10:45PM (#2680239) Homepage
      This isn't directly on topic, but it's important so I wanted to make sure you read this.

      USE PLENUM

      Yes, it costs more, but it meets building code, and isn't nearly so flammable. Please don't be cheap and use the PVC stuff that will help housefires spread wonderfully just to save $100.

  • by Keefesis ( 70341 ) <leprechaunpancho@@@yahoo...com> on Sunday December 09, 2001 @03:00PM (#2678896)
    As long as you're using shielded cat5 cable and your phone lines are shielded, you shouldn't have a problem running them through the same conduit. Be aware, however, that if you run your cat5 cable within 6 inches (safe margin) of electrical sources, you will see interference and will experience performance problems. I'm not sure what your electrical people are doing, but it's common to place electrical outlets near phone outlets (fax machines, cordless phones, etc). Just FYI, be aware of this.
    • by Fozz ( 9037 ) on Sunday December 09, 2001 @03:32PM (#2679051) Homepage

      Actually, phone lines are low-voltage and should not represent much of an interference problem with your ethernet signals. Keeping your CAT5 at least 6-12 inches away from any 120V AC lines running parallel is always a good idea.

      Always cross your CAT5 and 120V power cables as perpendicular as possible to avoid crosstalk.

  • Phone wire?!?? (Score:4, Informative)

    by atporter ( 5395 ) on Sunday December 09, 2001 @03:00PM (#2678897) Homepage
    Just use the Cat5 for everything. An RJ-11 will fit in an RJ-45 jack just fine. Tie it all back to a patch pannel in the basement and then you can patch phones/ethernet/whatever to your hearts content.
  • Fiber can be a pain in the ass to put in. Make sure you don't touch the actual glass... you'll never get those splinters out.
    If you have the means to put in fiber, though, go right ahead... but don't get secondary support equipment for it, as that might change by the time you want to put it into use.
  • Price (Score:5, Insightful)

    by utdpenguin ( 413984 ) <[moc.kcirdnek] [ta] [nhoj]> on Sunday December 09, 2001 @03:00PM (#2678903) Homepage
    Im just guessing at numbers, but fiber is expensive now. It will get cheaper. Lets say the Cat5 isn't worth replacing for 10 years or so. In ten years fiber will be a _lot_ cheaper. Possibly cheap enogh to offset the cost and trouble of rewiring? Dunno, just thinking aloud.
  • by puppetman ( 131489 ) on Sunday December 09, 2001 @03:00PM (#2678904) Homepage

    but why don't you set it up so that in future years you can put in what ever cable you want?

    I always imagined having a duct built into the floor of my house, running along the walls, with a grate over top. I would run whatever in there, be it fibre or cat-5, etc.

    And if I ever went wireless, I could just fill it up with beer and use a really long straw.
  • Run conduit (Score:2, Informative)

    by jalewis ( 85802 )
    If you run conduit, no matter what happens, you can run new cable later.

    If it was me I would run the cat5e now and include a string with the pull. Later you can attach whatever cable you want and pull it through. It will be difficult if you don't have conduit.

    My future plans include 802.11a, so I am not worried about fiber. I just need one run to the middle of the house for my AP. I am using 802.11b now and I am happy with the speed/wire trade off.

    Good luck!
  • by Toodles ( 60042 ) on Sunday December 09, 2001 @03:01PM (#2678909) Homepage
    By the sound of the post, you feel that this is an urgent matter before the drywall goes up. It doesn't have to be. What you should be concerning yourself with putting in is conduit, not the wiring, if this is a house you plan on living in for a good long time.

    With good conduit, running wires is a fairly painless process. Install the conduit, let the contractors install the drywall, then run the cat5, fiber, whatever. After X many years, if you decide you need to upgrade to fiber or whatever is current enough for your needs, pulling the existing wire and replacing will be a cinch. By putting in the wiring now instead of conduit, you are speeding up the depreciation and obsolescense (sp?) of your house, not increasing it. Good conduit even helps with events you didn't plan, such as if you figure out you need to pull RCA cables for house-wide stereo, or additional coax, or whatever.

    Toodles
    • Good point. Certainly a better approach than trying to predict what kind of networking technology will be "in" ten years from now!
    • by imrdkl ( 302224 ) on Sunday December 09, 2001 @03:32PM (#2679052) Homepage Journal
      Depending on the construction and how he will use the ceiling space, conduit could be quite a luxury. Most wood-frame houses dont have a speck of conduit, relying on romex through the upright members, typically 1-2 rooms per circuit. Conduit would be great, but requires a whole different kind of electrical contractor/installer, typically. (one who can use a pipe-bender quite proficiently)

      In any case, if you do use conduit, be sure to follow the rule of at least two, tagged fishlines on every pipe from every jbox, for later use of pulling new wire in to the existing pipe.

      Back on topic, I believe that ethernet in the walls is more than sufficient. One can always bridge to a fiber link at the termination in the future, but the last-mile question for fiber is far from being answered clearly, it seems.

      • by swb ( 14022 ) on Sunday December 09, 2001 @04:55PM (#2679327)
        Conduit would be great, but requires a whole different kind of electrical contractor/installer, typically. (one who can use a pipe-bender quite proficiently)

        High voltage electricians are all trained to use a pipe bender, and at least among the unscientific sampling of the ones I work with frequently, all prefer to EMT conduit even when they could get away with flexible armored.

        Low voltage guys seldom use metal pipe and probably aren't as experienced. It's hard to say what kind of guys are actually on the job at most wood stick construction new homes. The worst part of running pipe in a new home might be trying to figure out where it would run, locating and keeping accessable the jboxes, and convincing your builder that this is something worth messing with his schedule.

        The latter part is key, since the building, GC, and subs have wicked schedules that can get thrown when some homeowner wants to do something different in the middle of construction, especially if it involves a trade or skill they don't do on a normal basis.

    • Yes, you should absolutely use conduit. After 10, 20 or 40 years, you'll be swearing and kicking the walls when you realize you have to change all the wires and you don't have conduit (unless everything has gone wireless, but I doubt that).

      However, you should really think about what kind of conduit you plan to use. After 40 years, things tend to rotten, and if you have cheap conduit it might not last that long. And while installing it, you should make it the simplest task to upgrade all the cables. You still have to do that one day...

      And the cables you want to run really depend on what you use them for. But if you know you don't really need fiber now, you most probably don't need it after 5 or 10 years. Go with the cat5e. If you notice you need fiber after 10 years, fine, rewire your house, it will be easy because you used good conduits, and fiber will probably cost next to nothing after 10 years.
    • by OmniGeek ( 72743 ) on Sunday December 09, 2001 @06:22PM (#2679589)
      And if the contractor can't handle conduit (find a better contractor?!), you can do it yourself. Steel conduit is cheap (I know, 'cause I've done this), and conduit benders are not difficult to use. Of course, if you don't wanna use a conduit bender, you can buy prefab curved sections.

      A few things to keep in mind:

      0. Use METAL conduit rather than plastic - indefinite lifetime, RF shielding, and nailproof when hanging pictures. Also easily findable with stud-finder gadgets at need.

      1. Use BENDS rather than square corners (and insist the contractor do so -- inspect before accepting...). Makes pulling cable more fun, and VITAL for fiber (if it ever comes to that)

      2. If you do it yourself, make sure you debur the insides of all conduit ends with the little blade on the tubing cutter. It really sucks to have a short 'cause the conduit cut the insulation.

      3. Check local codes and the building inspector on how to GROUND the conduit properly (one probably grounds this to the building safety ground at the electrical service entrance -- a definite building-inspector question). The building inspector can be made into a very handy resource if you social-engineer the interaction properly - you want him to take you seriously, and to understand that you want to, and are able to, do things right and with proper permits; at this point, he ceases to be an obstacle and becomes an ally. Also, be real clear to the building department that your conduit is LOW-VOLTAGE wiring and NOT power wiring; the code requirements are different.

      Lastly, 3Com has a nifty mini-hub that fits into a wall box, seen on /. recently...
  • Combo (Score:5, Informative)

    by Karma 50 ( 538274 ) on Sunday December 09, 2001 @03:02PM (#2678914) Homepage
    How about this stuff [hometech.com]

    A lot more expensive than plain cat5 though.
  • by GC ( 19160 ) on Sunday December 09, 2001 @03:02PM (#2678915)
    You may not be aware of this but you can use your Cat-5E cable to run your telephones over.

    I don't think you'll need Fibre - doesn't Cat-5E support gigabit speeds?
  • Ten years from now will I need/want fiber? If you string another wire along with the CAT5 cable, you can use it to pull something else through in the future. Just make sure it doesn't bind anywhere. When you pull the new fiber/firewire/whatever through, pull another pullwire along with it.

    During the summers between college semesters I helped wire a factory. It involved pulling a lot of wires through pipes. We always pulled a few extra wires for spares and to act as pullwires.

  • Put in ducts and modular faceplates, so you can replace the cables when something better comes along. Have all the ducts go straight down to the basement, and a duct around the ceiling of the basement with access at each joint with a vertical duct, then put your router in some inobtrusve corner of the basement.

    Have fun.
    • If you're gonna put it in ducts--even in a single dwelling residential--check your local codes. They may require you to use plenum. Most business codes (and either the NEC or the TIA/EIA-568-A can't remember which one) requires that for offices cable installed in ducts must be plenum rated and installed in conduit inside the ducts.

      The danger is non-plenum cable gives off a lot of smoke while burning, if the cable is in the ducts this can quickly spread the smoke to areas that aren't on fire and hinder peoples escape from the building.

      Fire codes are basically designed to do two things, 1) slow down the spread of a fire 2) make it easy for people to escape. And if you can't see, you can't get out (so the theory goes), that's why plenum is sometimes required. (plus non-plenum burning vapours tend to create a strong acid when mixed with water, iirc).

      Long and short, always check your codes.

      Bryan
    • Running the conduits strait down to the basement is a good idea. From there you can run the wires above a false celing to your wireing closet. This would make adding new wires a snap, just start dropping wire down the conduit until you can see it in the basement. If the conduit is big so it doesn't get stuck on other wires you won't even need a string or anything to pull it through (you might need a little weight on the wire though).

      You could even put in some empty ducts for future expansion (maybe 3 or 4 on every wall) even if you don't need/want cable there right now. No need to even put the face plate in yet, you could always cut that later (just rememeber where they go!!!)

      As for what wires to use: Cat-5e is a great start. You can run basically everything over it, from your LAN (obviously) to your telephone, to your audio and even your TV. But if you leave room for upgrades it doesn't matter what the future holds...
  • Fiber is unlikely (Score:5, Informative)

    by demaria ( 122790 ) on Sunday December 09, 2001 @03:04PM (#2678926) Homepage
    Fiber is highly unlikely to be necessary or desirable in the next 10 to 20 years in residential housing. Install Cat5E cable, it'll handle gigabit which should be fast enough for just about everything.

    Instead of spending money on fiber, spend money to install conduit. Conduit conduit conduit! Conduit is nice since you can later on pull fiber or additional wires more easily.
  • In ten years... (Score:5, Insightful)

    by RedWolves2 ( 84305 ) on Sunday December 09, 2001 @03:05PM (#2678927) Homepage Journal
    In ten years everything will be 802.11. So does it really matter? Just run the cat5.
    • Re:In ten years... (Score:2, Informative)

      by cheetah ( 9485 )
      God, I hope not. 802.11b is slow, at only 11mbps it can take quite a while to copy anything larger than a 100meg. Backing up a few gigs would be a nightmare... 802.11a is 54mbps and that is not too bad. But I will stick with GigE so I can push +20Meg/sec to my sever...

      josh
  • Fiber breaks fairly easily - its a big problem. You might put it in there, and have it work fine for a long time, and then something breaks SOMEWHERE and you don't know where, but you do know that you've lost your connection. Copper is far more durable. If you put in the fiber and the CAT5, you could use the cable as a backup.

    Having said that, 100Mb per second is pretty fast for games, X-clients/servers and harddrive reads and writes, unless you really want all the computers to act like one computer. Maybe that's what you want. I don't really care myself. If I want to work on another computer, I walk over to the other one and sit down. So even in the future, I'll probably always be happy with CAT5.
  • by Maktoo ( 16901 ) on Sunday December 09, 2001 @03:06PM (#2678933) Homepage
    Right now, I wouldn't even consider using fiber.

    You would need a lot of other hardware to make it work.

    With Ethernet, hubs and switches are cheap... you can wire everything back to a patch box and from there have it connect to your ADSL or cable modem.

    I'm not sure what the costs are on actual fiber cable, but it's certainly not as cheap as CAT5. What's more, you would either need a NIC in your computer capable of accepting fiber (over $US300 I think) or you would need a Fiber-->CAT5 converter box at each point where fiber comes out of the wall. Those boxes aren't cheap either.

    Really, it just comes down to this. If you want super-fast communication between your computers in your house, and are willing to pay a hefty premium, them fiber it is. But it's not going to make your Internet connection much faster. Your Internet connection will only every be as fast as whatever the Cable or DSL modem has going out... and that's usually a 10Mbs connection running at 2Mbs download max.

    Personally... if you want scalability, I would just make sure that the CAT5 you string is high quality and has *all eight conductors*... that way it is good for Gigabit Ethernet... which is slowly coming down in price and is already more affordable than Fiber for LANs.

    enjoy
    • by Maktoo ( 16901 ) on Sunday December 09, 2001 @03:15PM (#2678969) Homepage
      Oh, I just thought of something.

      It will be a little more expensive, but you might want to think about stringing "STP" CAT5, instead of UTP... that's Shielded Twisted Pair instead of Unshielded.

      STP is what is plenum graded, so that it doesn't catch fire as easily. Also, it's better shielded against interference from other electrical sources that might be in the wall.

      It's not a requirement or anything... but it might be worth considering simply for safety reasons.
    • "If you want super-fast communication between your computers in your house, and are willing to pay a hefty premium, them fiber it is."

      Cat5E does gigabit. Current consumer hard drives can barely sustain flooding fast ethernet, let along gig. Fiber (and some will argue gig) to consumer and midrange machines are overkill and will remain so for some time.

      However, Linksys has just released an 8 port gigabit switch for $189.
    • >I'm not sure what the costs are on actual fiber cable, but it's certainly not as cheap as CAT5.

      The price (as of about 2 weeks ago) for 1,000 feet of bulk Cat5E (PVC) from www.datacommwarehouse.com is $99.99, plenum is $279.99, two-wire PVC fiber costs $329.99, and two-wire plenum fiber is $349.99.

      Yes, I know datacomm isn't the cheapest place out there. :)
  • Wireless (Score:3, Informative)

    by tetrad ( 131849 ) on Sunday December 09, 2001 @03:06PM (#2678936)
    Why not forgo the whole cabling experience and go wireless instead? You can connect every room in the house with a single hub. It's cheaper than buying the cable and hub/switch, and a whole lot more convenient.
    • ...as running through the street naked singing "I'm a little teapot, short and stout" is to modesty and sanity.

      No offense, but even the best wireless security solution can't compare to having an actual cat5 cable you can control access to.
    • I disagree. With wireless, you've got higher latency, considerably slower speeds due to it being a shared medium, and usually higher costs.

      With his golden opportunity with the walls down right now, there's no reason to forgo a nice Cat5 wiring. Wire is cheap, you can put gigabit ethernet over it (vs. 11Mbps currently for wireless 802.11b), you can use a switch in the network closet instead of a shared topology, and you don't have to worry about your neighbors snooping your local traffic.

      You can always use wireless later on if you really want to (like for laptops). However, don't use that as an excuse for laziness right now.
    • I like wireless, but I wouldn't use it if there's an affordable and convenient alternative. Why deal with the extra cost and security hassles if you don't need to?

      And wireless only gives you 11 megabits, as opposed to 100 megabits for wired ethernet. And that assumes there are no neighbors emiting local packets for you to collide with.

      It's curious that everybody assumes that, except for the cost of the transceivers, that wireless bandwith is free and unlimited. There's only so much radio spectrum to go around, and we're already running short, even without 3G cells and ubiquitous community nets.

  • Cat5 and Coax (Score:4, Informative)

    by Robert Hayden ( 58313 ) on Sunday December 09, 2001 @03:06PM (#2678937) Homepage
    You should run two drops of Cat5 and two drops of RG6 Coax to every "main" room you may have people. Run it to a central cross-connect in the basement or garage.

    The reason you want to run two coax drops is that if you get a dual-tuner sattelite decoder (like a DirectTV TiVo) you will need to lines going out to your dish or to your multiswitch (which splits the signal between >2 lines, so you can put receivers in multiple rooms).

    You could also run a Left/Right RCA audio system to each room, but audio will travel decently over Cat5, so you shouldn't have to worry about that.

    Fiber would be useful, but frankly you don't need it now because nothing we are doing iwll need fiber probably for 10 years. If you want to prep for it, you can run conduit (probably 1.5" would be sufficient) to each room, to make pulling new cables in (or pulling old cables out) easier in 5 or 10 years. Run it to a modular mounting jack so you can change stuff out if need be.

    Having just recently gotten my DirectTV TiVo (and hacked it to 146 hours of storage), I know my next house is gonna need twin coax to every main room. :-)
  • ...do you really want to have to standardize on fiber adapters for all your devices?

    Besides, GigE over copper is here now. I've just purchased an old house that needs a lot of electrical work -- while the walls are open, I plan on running Cat 6 STP cabling to my drops.

    GigE might be the last gasp for copper. Then again, some were saying that about Fast Ethernet when that debuted.

    Trying to build in anticipation of what the standard will be in 2012 is an expensive crapshoot. Go with what works now (i.e. Cat 5e/6) and count on the size of the installed base to ensure continued support for it.
  • Shielded conduits would be more useful. More expensive now, but makes it dead simple to upgrade ten years from now.
  • by linuxbert ( 78156 )
    Rather then running seperate conduite for cableing, use the cold air returns. talk to the HVAC (heating/vent/Air cond) and makesure that you have a main return running straight from the basement to the atic, and floor and celling returns in each room (good practice for ventilation anyway.) And you should have no problem running plenum rated cable (fibre, cat5e whatever) through them.

    as an asside, if you plan on having 1 room in the house with most of your equipment, add extra registers to get more Cooling in summer and dont forget about fans in the ducts to improve air circulation)
  • by dfeldman ( 541102 ) on Sunday December 09, 2001 @03:09PM (#2678945) Homepage
    I have pulled cable in several new construction projects and I have a few tips that will save you a lot of headaches in the future:
    • Run conduit. Big conduit. There's a lot of space between your walls so why not leave yourself the room you will need to expand later?
    • You can buy 25-pair (!) Cat5e cable. It costs about twice as much as 4-pair but it is well worth it for expansion reasons. There's not a whole lot you can't do with 25 pairs.
    • Don't forget to buy plenum wiring, which does not emit toxic fumes when it burns. It's probably code in your area. I have seen bean counting managers cheap out and buy generic cable, and get fined thou$ands of dollars for it.
    • Coax isn't a bad idea, especially in a residential installation. You never know when you will want cable/DSS in a room.
    • Run a string between any two points where it makes sense, and mark the strings so you know what you're pulling later.
    • Don't bother with fiber. It is overpriced and will remain so for quite a while. Copper is good enough for gigabit ethernet and will provide all the bandwidth you need (within one building at least) for a very long time to come.

    Good luck with the project!

    df
    • Don't forget to buy plenum wiring, which does not emit toxic fumes when it burns. It's probably code in your area.

      Correct me if I'm wrong, but I thought plenum wiring was only required in airspaces. I though wiring enclosed in conduit did not have to be plenum-rated to meet code.
    • There's not a whole lot you can't do with 25 pairs.
      Oh Lord. You're right, of course. But putting that much capacity into a residential network still boggles my mind.
    • by coyote-san ( 38515 ) on Sunday December 09, 2001 @03:40PM (#2679078)
      One other point is that conduit pipes should be run vertically. Running a 2" pipe through all of your wall studs is a Bad Idea, but running such a pipe vertically is another matter entirely. It also makes it easier to install the insulation. (You want insulation on interior walls for the sound proofing. A little money now will save a lot of headaches when your kids are teenagers.)

      You also want a large pipe that's a straight shot from attic to basement/crawlspace.

      The idea is that you have good access in attic and basement/crawlspace, so they don't need special treatments. But walls are a real pain once they're sealed, so you want to keep it as simple as possible. And nothing is simplier than a large vertical pipe with no bends in it. Even if the pipe is completely empty (e.g., you sealed in a few extra pipes "just in case"), you can pull a line with nothing but a string and a lead weight.
    • by dgou ( 542390 ) on Sunday December 09, 2001 @04:27PM (#2679231)
      My SO, a data wrangler from a local university says:

      Great list. Esp. marking the strings, you'll really want to know what is where.
      25 pair sounds cool, however it is a termination nightmare unless you're just going to use it specifically from point to point as your major house backbone and have it premade and preterminated for your situation. If you terminate it yourself you might be able to maintain 100Mb, but likely not and certainly not Gig. Unless there is a whole new 25 pair solution out there. Big conduit to run a plethora of different cables (except power of course) is a more general solution.

      I would also add that you want more than one outlet per room. Depending on your builder, it could be something that you'd have to octopus up (or down) from a central point, or you might be able to run in between the floor boards to get opposite wall coverage (or three or four wall coverage depending on your layout.

      One thing is for sure, there is never enough bandwidth, and you don't know what you'll want to run in the future.

      The house I bought was already built, and has pathetic insulation which is not easily fixed. I'm planning on moving the "server farm" and "main hub" between the attic (in winter) and somewhere lower in the house in summer.

      Consider also that where-ever you've picked for your central hub might become ideal for something else (kid's attic room, enclosed hot tub in basement, whatever), and since its so easy now, I would be inclined to run the conduit so you could have two (or maybe three, depending on the structure of your house) alternative spots.

      It might also be cool to run a room or three with a few extra outlets for gaming/multimedia/"record"-making/"movie"-making parties, efforts, etc. (I'm thinking of "Duality" ((Lost the URL, darn!)).

  • Run Cat 5 but... (Score:3, Informative)

    by Codifex Maximus ( 639 ) on Sunday December 09, 2001 @03:13PM (#2678959) Homepage
    don't secure the wire to the studs in the wall. That way whenever fiber is more prevalent, you can use the Cat5 to pull the fiber down into the wall from the attic.

    Pull the Cat 5 to a central place down inside your house - locate your router/hub there - maybe even your home server.

    Think about providing excellent grounding and maybe even heatsink capability to your server closet. Run a separate breakered power to the server closet.

    Run coaxial cable for TV - double shielded - to each room and have it go either to the attic for split or better yet have them terminate at the power mast outside the house - leave plenty of extra cable.

    Wire your house for security prior to putting in the insulation - insulation and sheetrock guys just love to cut wires that are in their way. :/
  • It's hard to predict what you'll want to run between your walls in the future. Technology changes every few years - but house ownership can last for decades.

    The key is to install conduit between key locations in your house. It usually isn't that hard to run cables between the basement and the first floor, or from the attic to the second floor. But it can be a big effort to run a wire from the basement to the 2nd floor. Or to get a cable to a location where it isn't accessible from the attic or the basement.

    When I had my house built, I installed a conduit from the wiring panel in the basement all the way up to the attic, with access points on the first and second floors. I also installed a conduit behind two bedroom walls on the second floor - walls which are diffcult to get behind without a lot of demolition.

    Now if I want to bring in a new fiber or CATV or doorbell, it's very easy to draw the cable from the basement to the attic, and it's easy to cleanly distribute the cable to any room in the house.

    My only mistake was a lack of a conduit between my house and detached garage.
  • I just did this... (Score:3, Informative)

    by pherret ( 199762 ) on Sunday December 09, 2001 @03:17PM (#2678981)
    My father was building his new house and wanted it "wired for the future". My brother and I were to develop his idea and install it (after the electrician and before the drywall).

    We decided that is wasn't practical to run fiber. How much speed to really think you will need? How much faster can a home user get? Even if the broadband ISPs upgrade their system to allow anything faster than a maximum of 10mbps...are you _REALLY_ going to need that?

    If you are concerned about the speed in your home area network, then just make sure your network equipment is 100meg...that should be more than plenty for every person in those six rooms to be swapping high-quality multimedia back and forth.

    The point is, fiber really isn't for the home user...it's more for other intensive bandwidth situations. What I can definately recommend is that if you can afford it and it won't break your budget...then by all means go for it!

    However, if it _will_ break your budget, or you want to spend that money on a bunch of X-10 equipment for a semi-Jetson-type house, then run conduit and pull strings. So if you ever get the cash or get the itch to install fiber, all you gotta do is attach it to a pull string and go...it will slide nicely through conduit.

    As for the phone and other stuff...just run Cat-5 all the way through. You can use it for phone and sound (maybe other things). If you want video, just run a coax to each room and get a fancy distribution panel to manage all this neat stuff. I wouldn't recommend running S-Video throughout. Have you ever bought a 6-foot s-video cable? They are expensive. Coax does its job just fine. Make sure you run the high quality stuff.

    Of course, if you run fiber you can pipe it all through the same wire, but each room will need an EXPENSIVE thingy to split all signals to the designated device.
  • House Wiring (Score:5, Informative)

    by oldzoot ( 60984 ) <morton.james@co m c a st.net> on Sunday December 09, 2001 @03:18PM (#2678989)
    I wired my own house a few years ago.

    Here is some advice based on what I did. Note that I was at the time a licensed communications wiring contractor, so the house is wired a litte more than perhaps is usefull, but here goes.

    1. Put muliple locations in each room. I put to faceplates in each bedroom, typically near a corner and opposite each other ( diagaonally opposite corners ) a cable from the outlet can be run along either adjacent wall for convienience in locating phones or computers. In each outlet are two cat 5 data cables and 1 4pair telephone cable. In one of the two outlets is an RG6 CATV cable.

    2. Home run telephone wires - I ran all the telephone cables directly from the outlet to a telephone junction box in the garage which was mounted directly above the one from the phone company. The phone company box faces outside, mine faces inside and there are some holes in the 2X4 seperating them for cables to run through. I mounte 4 type 66 punchblocks in the inside box and terminated all 32 cables there. All multiple jumpering etc. is done in that box.

    I ran all the data wiring ( 48 cables ) to 4 dual gang boxes inside the master bedroom closet. Using ortronics IMO2 dual gang faceplates with 6 double port modules, I got 48 ports in the 4 outlets and its is not cludgy like a patchpanel on a swingout door would be- it has a finished look. I also got the electrician to put a utility outlet inside the closet close to the ports to power the switch and localtalk bridge.

    3. Put a telephone outlet near your CATV outlets - if you want to use satellite tv or some other service which requires a telephone connection it will be very good to have.

    4. Put data outlets in common rooms - the livingroom, dining room den etc. These areas could end up as common homework computer areas for the kids. I have a table in the living room and one in the dining room ( we eat in the kitchen ) with some older computers on them that the kids use for homework.

    Note that the contractors installers may be very helpful if you offer a 6 pack or two of beer to help grease the skids. I got all kinds of built-in bookshelves, nooks and other cool customizations this way.

    Another suggestion !! Put in the return line for a circulating hot-water system during construction. If you can not afford the pump now, you can add it later, but it is a pain to put the return line in.

    Also consider insulating hot water lines and putting insulation inside the inner walls to give some soundproofing.

    Good Luck

    Zoot
  • I don't see anyone that's mentioned it yet, but you should probably run CAT-7 for gigabit ethernet speeds. I agree that most gigabit ethernet equipment is expensive at the moment, but prices will no doubt fall soon (New G4 macs come with gigabit ethernet, including the G4 Powerbook (!) ). Gigabit ethernet is the future as far as home use. Fiber is a pain, CAT-7 is a copper wire so you should be able to make your own connectors. I'm not sure what the price point currently is on CAT-7.
  • by Anonymous Coward on Sunday December 09, 2001 @03:23PM (#2679019)
    I recently wired a new house. Here's my experiences with it.

    I wired the house with cable and two CAT5e cables to each telephone housing, plus security and some audio cabling to a few select areas. I also set up the internal vacuum system.

    Do Not, I repeat, DO NOT wire anything before the electrician has wired for power. Plan with the electrician so that you can make sure your wire is at least 1 foot, preferably 2 feet away from his wire when running in parallel, and otherwise crosses at oblique (near to 90 degrees) angles. Master electricians are smart, but the workers they employ are morons. We had to yank out a lot of wiring because the electricians laid power cable in all sorts of unfortunate places right next to ours. YOU HAVE BEEN WARNED.

    Do nail in wire protector plates onto wood just like your electrician does for the power cables. They're to keep the drywallers from wrecking your wiring with their drywall nails.

    Do consider running a little conduit, but only a little. Don't conduit the whole thing: what we wound up doing was running conduit from the basement up to the attic. The house is two-story. That way if we absolutely had to, we could wire things in the future without massive rebuilding.

    Do run everything (phone, cable, network, fiber) in a star configuration to a central hub.

    Do do both the telephone and networking and cable yourself. It's simple. Don't pay the electrician to wire for telephone if you're going to wire for networking; you're just wasting money.

    Do Not use plenum, braided, or shielded CAT5e cable. Plenum cable has basically one use: to be run through air ducts in old office buildings as a fire precaution. Shielded CAT5e will turn your network into an antenna if not properly grounded. In general, you don't need it unless you're running along with lots of electrical lines in close conduit areas. Braided cable is only for patch-cord use.

    Do consider the new combination cable available, which has fiber, cable, CAT5e, low-power DC, and audio all in one bundle. But it's a pain to wire because it has to be bent at very gradual angles. Might be a good way to go though, and cheaper.

    Do not expect that security is wired in a similar fashion. In particular, 4-wire smoke detectors cannot be wired in a star configuration at all: they must be wired in a specific, unusual serial topology.

    Do remember that your hub must be in a locked area.

  • by Doctor K ( 79640 ) on Sunday December 09, 2001 @03:24PM (#2679020) Homepage
    I just bought a house and instead of wiring it up, I just use 802.11b for the bedroom computers. However, my 802.11b access point / firewall also has a switched hub, so my workstations are hooked up with CAT5. This is more than fast enough for any kind of internet connection you are likely to get in the near future.

    Don't listen to the ... ahem ... "experts" telling you to install fiber. In my day job, I work in research on fiber optics technology (mostly for 40 Gb/s+ DWDM long haul and metro networks). Fiber equipment that I am familar with is not made for the consumer market.

    Would you even know what types of fiber to buy? (multi-mode / single-mode, C-band / L-band / Extended-L band, ...) Or what kind of connectors you would need? Or do you have the access to the equipment necessary to splice fibers (it's not cheap to do it right)? Do you know what kinds of equipment to attach to the end of the fiber (modulators, switches, splitters, NICs ...)? And exactly what are you going to hook up that requires fiber's speed?

    If you are worried about an upgrade path, the smart thing to do is install conduits. When fiber goes to the consumer market, you will be ready.

    Kevin
  • A hole in Cambridge (Score:2, Interesting)

    by Tim Ward ( 514198 )
    Everyone is telling you to put conduit in ... this reminds me:

    The Cambridge University Computing Service, several years back, wanted to run a network round the city to connect to various University departments, colleges etc. To pay fo this they had to persuade all these bodies to cough up a significant amount of money as their share of the capital costs.

    Trouble was that people thought they were being asked to pay for high-tech stuff which would go out of date in a few years, so the marketing job was to persuade them that they were actually being asked to pay for an extremely low tech hole in the ground, through which any appropriate type of cable could easily and cheaply be drawn in years to come.

    This worked. The hole got built.
  • I just did this (Score:5, Informative)

    by renehollan ( 138013 ) <[rhollan] [at] [clearwire.net]> on Sunday December 09, 2001 @03:29PM (#2679045) Homepage Journal
    Well, worse: I bought a house already built.

    I ended up running 2 runs of Cat5e and 2 runs of quad-shielded RG-6 to 6 drops.

    You will want the coax... trust me. While I'd like to run everythng over UTP or fiber, the costs of locating things like VCRs, and satellite receivers at a head end, and streaming video digitally are prohibitive compared to the costs of running the coax. You may want to plan for the day when everything is streamed over IP and carried on an ethernet or fiber physical layer, but I think it is far better to have dead cable in the wall than to use horribly expensive equipment today as opposed to your neighbor who just hooks up the new TV to the cable outlet and is done.

    Fiber. I didn't run any, but mostly because of the cost -- it's still too expensive. Also, don't forget headend terminations for all those fiber lines -- they are expensive. If you can afford it, by all means. In my case, I figure I'll sell the house and build a new one before I have a real pressing need for fiber: am I really going to want to stream full-resolution uncompressed video room to room? I doubt it.

    Do put in as many drops as you think you'll need, and then some. You have an advantage over me: your walls aren't up yet. Plan for a minimum of one per room, more if there are multiple entrances. For example, many central family rooms open up to formal dining/living rooms and kitchen -- place the outlet on the "wrong" wall and you'll have to snake a cable across an entryway... not cool.

    If you can afford the cabling, make EACH 110VAC outlet have a co-located (but not sharing the box-- that violates code) coax/data drop. That's excessive, and you immediately have to separate the AC and other cables to avoid interference, but you'll have a drop whereever you need one. Personally, I'd probably stick with one outlet per continuous wall segment, more for bigger rooms.

    I ran 2xCat5e and 2xRG-6 (quad-shielded). You can get combo cable (speedwrap) that contains this (with or without fiber) in a single jacket that makes for easy pulling, but expect to pay double over individual cables. If you're paying for installation, the reduced labour might pay for the more expensive cable. Note: the reason for two runs of coax is in case you want to run a video stream back to the headend, like, perhaps a baby monitor camera. However, with recent PVR having TWO tuners, you'll find you need to use both coax cables, espescially with satellite systems (the receiver sends a signal selecting satellite and polarization to the multiswitch over the coax -- you don't have all channels on the cable at once). If you want to do this and send video back to the headend you may need three coax cables.. though a cheap PC and webcam might do the trick over the Cat5-e instead (and I can think of creative uses of satellite diplexers to use two coaxes for two satellite signals, one cable/off air signal, and a backfeed, but I haven't tried it).

    As for plugging phones into RJ-45s... why bother? Just terminate one of the Cat5e cables in an RJ-14 jack, leaving one pair not connected... you can have up to three lines on that RJ-14. Alternately, split it out in the box to two RJ-14s. You can always require for ethernet later, if you have to (or use a PBX that requires 8 wires). This also ensures that you don't accidently plug the phone in the wrong outlet (confusing the coax ports is bad enough).

    I'd post more, but have to go.

  • I did this to my house last year.

    If you go the Cat5e route, be absolutely certain to pay the extra few bucks to get Plenum rated cable instead of PVC. Plenum rated cable won't put off toxic fumes if it catches fire. Also, your local fire marshall will love you.

    I recommend running wire, the night that only one side of the drywall is placed, this way you have something to anchor it to and get a reference of where your plugs are and need to be.

    Phone cables now are typically Cat5 or Cat5e. Don't use them unless you must, crosstalk can be bad.

    Lastly run 2 cables everywhere a computer can fit. Do you want an automated house in the future? Plan now! Maybe you don't but when you sell the house do you want that as a selling point? HTH
  • Building Codes (Score:3, Insightful)

    by eander315 ( 448340 ) on Sunday December 09, 2001 @03:39PM (#2679074)
    Be aware that building codes may prohibit you from doing any of this. Most likely you'll be fine, but I would check first.

    Secondly, make sure you're using the right kind of cat-5 for the job. PVC type is cheaper, but is less resistant to heat and can cause noxious fumes if burned. Plenum type insulation is more resistant to heat, and is certified for use in air ducts because it doesn't produce the fumes that PVC will. Unfortunately, Plenum is more expensive. In any case, keep track of heat sources when you're wiring. The fireplace and oven, for instance, may cause you problems if you run cable right behind them.

    You may want to run 2 different colors of cat-5, one for voice and one for data. Cat-5 can handle up to 4 voice lines through one cable. In any case, make sure you label everything.

    Finally, don't forget to run coax (as well as any other cables you may need for ANYTHING, such as speaker cable, RCA, etc.), as you may need to add a TV or cable modem connection. No one likes having their cable modem sitting on the TV. e

  • I am preparing to build my own house as well and have been looking at this very issue.

    What I have decided was to run 6+ normal CAT5e wires to each room. This may seem like a lot but... Comready.com [comready.com] has 1000' spools for 40+$ so price is not that great of an issue.

    Now for the secret ingredients. First of all.. For network just use 1 or more standard CAT5e cables to do that in each room. You can then run up to 4 phone lines on another CAT5e cable. You then have 3 left.

    Milestek.com [milestek.com] has cat5 baluns that let you transmit everything from S-video [milestek.com] to Broadband Video [milestek.com] in case you ever want video in any room.

    That also leaves a couple cables free for intercoms and such.

    If you want to lessen the cable runs or hook more things up in each room in the future you get something like the NJ-100 [slashdot.org] that we saw the article on slashdot about a couple weeks ago.

    Happy home hacking!
  • A big question to ask your self is are you running 10 or 100Mbit ? If your only running 10, your only using 5 wires out of the cat 5 cable. (Or is it 4) 100Mbit uses all of the cable. If your only running 10 (Which I couldn't understand, with 100Mbit cards so cheap these days) You can run the phone line inside of the same cable.

    Personally, I would run 2 cables in each room. Unless you have 2 offices. Think about it, with 100Mbit you can have a smaller hub in each room if you *REALLY* need it. Chances are, you won't be using that much bandwidth all day long.

    Plus, with the new 56Mbit wireless standard that was just released, I am not sure how many people will keep using cat5 cable across there house. I have my main machines running at 100Mbit (There in the same room), and everything else in the house is via wireless connection. Once I get IPSec working, it will be less of a hassle to worry about the security of the network :)

    At any rate, 2 in each room seems plenty for most home LANs. Unless you have 400 computers. My old house at 40 machines running 24/7, and 100Mbit was more or less required. (Don't ask :)
  • I guess fiber will always be faster but it seems like wireless will be the way to go. I'm sure they'll have good speeds by then.

    Of course, I wonder if sunspots will affect wireless internet?
  • Put conduit in. One box per wall per room. Make sure you've got big enough pipes, an even distribution of the pipes through the walls, and a home-run room (or whatever they call it) where everything can come together nicely. (Ours is in the mud room.)

    That way you can change the cabling, and easily add more as the occasions arise.

    I have Cat5E running through-out the house. The only rooms I didn't wire were the bathrooms, and I already regret it.

  • by dew ( 3680 ) <david@weekly.TOKYOorg minus city> on Sunday December 09, 2001 @04:02PM (#2679154) Homepage Journal
    Here's the straight-up truth. You don't know what you need 10 years from now! Neither does anybody else in this forum. 5 or 10 years down the pipe, you're going to want to drop in some new cabling/communications wiring, right? Maybe you will want to run audio/video cables through the walls like one poster suggested. But the point is not to NOW lay every single possible cable you'd want. What you want to do is to future-proof your house.

    In my opinion, the best way to do that is to use conduit. Conduit will let you easily drop in new cables to your house's framework. That way, just drop in your cat 5e and telephone wiring now, and then, as you need it, drop in other transport media.

    I might caution you as to using long-haul analog cabling media, like stereo RCA - long, straight wires make excellent antennas and the audio quality by the time it actually got to your speakers would be undoubtedly subpar. If you have the money, running something like optical S/PDIF would make more sense, as it's digital and won't lose signal quality over the kind of runs you're likely to have in your house.

    Good luck, and kudos on putting together a fabulous new home!
  • by rveno1 ( 470619 ) on Sunday December 09, 2001 @04:04PM (#2679156)
    of Course it is a no brainer to wire your house with cat5e (in fact when my dad redid our house 8 years ago he made sure they installed cat5)

    But from another perspective AFTER you wire the house (and before the drywall is up) run through your house with a CAMCORDER and record where all the wires are placed this will become an invaluable resource when you have to do expansion!
    • But from another perspective AFTER you wire the house (and before the drywall is up) run through your house with a CAMCORDER and record where all the wires are placed this will become an invaluable resource when you have to do expansion!

      No, don't use a camcorder. Use a camera (digital or film), get prints, and *organize them into a notebook*. Clearly label each page, ("Dining room, South") etc.. Make notes on each page as to what kinds of cable are where. Update the notebook after construction is complete as to what box is hooked to what cable.

      Hardcopy prints properly stored last for decades, and the specs on the MK1 eyeball won't change in that timeframe either. (Hardcopy notebooks can also be easily transferred to the next owner with no compatibility problems.)
  • by Spinality ( 214521 ) on Sunday December 09, 2001 @04:04PM (#2679160) Homepage
    Lots of good comments here. I have nothing to add about the fiber/UTP question, other than it might be a little premature to drop fiber everywhere; but here are some other UTP notes from my experience:

    Consider using a modular connector system like this one [levitontelcom.com]. I saved a lot of time and hassle using them and the result looks great. You can also intermix CATV, voice, data etc. however you like.

    Use a star from a cable closet (could be a cabinet in your garage or next to the water heater, doesn't matter). Consider running everything to a patch panel. If you don't want to spring for the connectors etc. of a patch panel, at least create a 'virtual patch panel' where every circuit is tagged and accessible. Leave good documentation in the cabinet 'cause you'll forget what goes where.

    Follow the Cat5 specs: minimal bends, minimal tension when pulling cable, loose cable ties, no regular tie intervals, cross AC power perpendicularly and rarely. Pick the cabling spec you'll use and stick to it. Avoid doing what I had to do: running voice on the unused two pairs of my 100Mbs data circuits (even though I've had zero problems).

    Be sure you have power near your drops and plenty of power and some shelf space in your closet. You'll be terminating your outside internet connectivity here as well (DSL, cable modem, etc.) so be sure to plan space accordingly for routers, console connections, hubs, UPS, etc.

    See the remarks elsewhere here about using plenum cable if you're not installing conduit. But conduit would let you use fiber or other more advanced media in the future.

    Invest in some cheap test equipment so you can verify continuity, correct pinouts, etc. in all your cables.

    HTH -- Spiny

  • A few considerations (Score:3, Interesting)

    by Manuka ( 4415 ) on Sunday December 09, 2001 @04:10PM (#2679179) Homepage

    Since this is new construction, go the extra mile and feed each data outlet with some sort of conduit (PVC, EMT, or flexible). That way, when you want to upgrade or expand, it's a no-brainer and you don't have to rip things apart. EMT conduit has the added bonus of providing RF shielding to your copper cabling, provided it's properly grounded (which it should be). This also gives you the advantage of only needing to put in the plumbing before you put up the sheetrock, and then running the actual wire later.

    Also, Leviton makes a very nice modular structured media system that allows you to do neat things like audio and video distribution in addition to phone and data - they have modular patch panels that make it very easy to do.

    Lastly, whatever you do, TAKE PICTURES of everything you do before you put the sheetrock up - you'll want them for reference when you make changes later.

  • by nuintari ( 47926 ) on Sunday December 09, 2001 @04:21PM (#2679212) Homepage
    My expiriance with wiring from the ground up is that you cannot plan for everything. You'll always think of something else that you wanna do with your existing scheme, and need to pull more wire. So conduits are the only option.

    As for fiber, I've never had to pay for it, but I've had to work with it. Its not worth the effort to use it, go high quality cat-5, and if ya want, then ya can go GigE. I'm told fiber is cheap to buy, expensive, and hard to run, and the hardware to talk over it is murderously expensive. But maybe even the cable itself is expensive, I dunno, used it, don't like it, don't wanna think about paying for it.

    Conduits, and loads of them, will make your life easier, and will greatly improve the value of your home, wish my house had conduits, but mine predates WW2..... and has power consumtion issues. *cries*

    As for what to put in the cables, its whatever ya wanna do with it. Me, right now, I;d run s-video, cat5, and coax, and maybe whatever the current "buzz" cable type is, and at least 4 outlets in each small room, 6 to 8 in big rooms. Else, your wife/significant other will go mad when she can't move the TV. And put em fairly close to your electrical outlets, so ya can just take all your cables that are close together, and tie em together with zip ties, and make the mess behind your euipment a little more pleassent.
  • Wireless? (Score:4, Insightful)

    by rknop ( 240417 ) on Sunday December 09, 2001 @04:40PM (#2679278) Homepage

    I would run cat-5 cable if I were you. It will be useful for the forseeable future... and who knows what you will want to have run in 10 years? Redo it when the time comes. In the mean time, for a house network, it's hard to imagine 100Mb/s not being sufficient for several years.

    I've run cat-5 cable in two houses. After a few months, you forget how painful it was and are just grateful to have it. In my old house, which was very small, I only wired a couple of rooms, but it was nice once it was there. In the new house, I only wired a single room. I intended to wire several more... but instead got myself a couple of wireless cards. The desktop has a card, and I have a second for the laptop. I run them in Ad-Hoc mode. It's much more convenient this way. I had intended to have lots of drops wired in, so that I could run my laptop in whatever room, but now I can do that with a very minimum of pain. More expensive, yes, but more flexible and much easier to install in the first place.

    (The one wire runs between the room with my desktop and the cable modem, and the room with my Wife's desktop. Since both computers stay in one place all the time, it makes sense to have wires for them. Since my Linux desktop is also the house router, it has three network cards: one for the cable modem, one for the house net, and one wireless card. I have two different private 192.168.x.x subnets in just my one house....)

    -Rob

  • by jackal! ( 88105 ) on Sunday December 09, 2001 @04:56PM (#2679332) Homepage

    If you're going to do this, and do this right, might as well have fun.

    Run an indistinct wire, (go for red or something equally ominous) along with everything else.

    Ten years from now when you're pulling the old stuff with your buddies look terribly surprised or upset to see it. Claim that you have no idea to what it is, but always insist that THEY cut it any time one gets in your way...

  • by Nonesuch ( 90847 ) on Sunday December 09, 2001 @06:00PM (#2679532) Homepage Journal
    I would not run fiber now.

    What I would do is build a patch panel or wiring closet in a basement or similar location, with all telephone/data/audio cabling to other parts of the house home-run to this location.

    If you run 'smurf' (flexbible blue fire-rated plastic tubing) to each room, and two each to bedrooms, media room, then you should be ready for anything.

    When you run the smurf, draw 2xCat5e to each room along with any necessary speaker cable. Most fire codes will permit you to leave in a 'pull line' of a code-accepted material, so you can easily draw more cables (fiber, etc) as needed.

    When running the 'smurf' tubing, try to avoid running in parallel with power conduits, or if you must, maximize the separation. Where you pass power lines, try to intersect at right angles.

  • Some thoughts.... (Score:4, Insightful)

    by chrisd ( 1457 ) <chrisd@dibona.com> on Sunday December 09, 2001 @06:37PM (#2679624) Homepage
    Some things I've run into with my basement remodel and upgrading a 1936 place for modern data and phone. The previous owenr updated the electric froom hook and look to conduit.

    1....You want to be careful about running parallel data/phone, audio,video and power close to each other. Even with high quality cable, you can have problems.

    2.....Do not strand boxes with wire inside them. Sealing over live boxes is a huge no-no. Why? Because what if you drive a nail into an active box. Many municipalistes will force you to correct this if you want to move.

    3.....You cannot route wires through heating /ac ducts. Probably ovious, but I thought I'd note it.

    4.....Always run more cat-5 than you need. If you are pulling two lines for net and phone, pull another. It's no real extrta cash and coudl save you later. Also, it's nice if you want to pull an extra line that is outside the firewall to your office for guests.

    5.....Think about where you want your wireless for home coverage. I have a smaller house, so I don't have any problem, but if my house were more spread out, I'd probably hav eto move the antenna out of the basement, necessitating a run of cat-5 to wherever, with nearby power. It's either that or run a very long antenna line.

    6.....Power, power, power. A computer + Laser Printer + Ups + Monitor + other gee gaws will suck up at least a 20 amp circuit. You don't want to over load a circuit. That's bad. I'm running 3 seperate circuits for the home office. 1 for fridge and other stuff, 1 for computer geear and 1 for lighting.

    7.....Check references for all contractors if you aren't plannign on pulling bits yourself.

    8.....Get familiar with your local codes. They are there to protect you, generally. Finding out where you are required to do GFCI circuits alone can save you trouble later.

    Good luck.

  • by Peter H.S. ( 38077 ) on Sunday December 09, 2001 @09:06PM (#2680026) Homepage
    The question is should I run fiber? I really don't know how much the cable costs since I don't know what cable to use. It is much easier to run cable
    before the drywall goes in so I want to make an informed decision now. Ten years from now will I need/want fiber?"


    The only reason to run fiber is if the needed cable length, exceed recommended CAT5e length.
    Fiber has several disadvantages (I am no cable expert); Connectors; There is a plethora of competing connectors. The most common; SC and ST connectors are rather bulky, and doesn't really work beyond 1Gbps. The new breed of small form connectors for >1Gbps hasn't been certified yet.
    If you plan to run fiber "end-to-end", you will have a really limited supply of products to choose from, pay premium prices, and to some extent be tied up with
    with whatever connector you choose to begin with.
    Changing or making the end-termination on fiber, is much more expensive on fiber, than on copper. (the SMF connector "VF-45" from 3M claims to be the cheapest to use, when doing end-to-end fiber).

    The price difference between even a managed 24p 100TX switch and a 24p 100 FX (fiber) switch is significant. The price on 1000 SX fiber equipment is also much higher than 1 GBIC copper equipment.

    We just evaluated upgrading our fiber backbone from 10Mbit to either 100FX or 1000SX. (we run a non-profit ISP for 300 apartments), and the price difference between a using a fiber or a copper core switch is very high indeed. If it wasn't for the fact, that our cable length requirements exceed Cat 5e/6, it would probably be cheaper to abandon the fiber and re-wire with copper.

    Using fiber-converters (transceivers) also sucks; they cost too much (one needed for every connected device), is yet another source for network problems, and requires yet another power plug.

    Actually I believe, that the money saved from investing in fiber and fiber equipment now, could pay for a totally fiber re-wiring if the need for such really should arise into the future.

    I really think you will be much better off using copper. People in the know claims, that even though Class D/Cat 6 (200MHz) isn't certified as a standard yet (?), the commercial "Cat 6" cabling systems availably now, should conform to the coming standard. So Cat 6 should be a much better long term investment than fiber. AFAIK Cat 6 should do 10Gbps. Again, people who knows much more than I do, claims that the present standard for multi mode fiber (50 and 62,5 Micron)
    doesn't do more than 1,2 Gbps reliably, and is a "dead" standard like Cat 5, and 5e. The coming fiber standards /type (10Gbps) probably named "Laser optimized multimode fiber" LOMMF or OM3 is still in the works.

    To summon up;
    Cat 5e is the cheap and tried solution. If future needs doesn't go beyond 1Gbps, then why not.

    Cat 6 is slightly more expensive, but is much more "future proof" (10Gbps). Perhaps one is still advised to buy a complete system, from the same vendor though.
    It allready seems, that Cat 6 rapidly has become the choice when people wire new offices.

    Present day fiber standards are not future proof (1,2Gbps), too expensive; not only the fiber cabling systems, but all devices that need to connect with it, and is probably something best left to a professional electrician to install.

    Peoples advice about conduit and pull wires, are probably the real key to a long term investment.
    A cheap ethernet tester will probably pay for it self too, if you are going to make a lot of cables.
  • What I did (Score:3, Informative)

    by b1t r0t ( 216468 ) on Sunday December 09, 2001 @09:15PM (#2680041)
    First of all, you've got the (potential) advantage of new construction. In my case, when I was shopping for a house this summer, one of the things I was looking for was a single-story house, so I could have access to all the walls from the attic. (In Austin you can't have a basement without using lots of dynamite.) With new construction, your best bet would be lots of 1" inner diameter PVC conduit going all over the house to empty electrical boxes. Make sure they don't run parallel to the electrical wires!

    What I did was pull eight drops of six cat-5 and one RG-6 to six rooms. (Actually only seven RG-6 drops because I ran out.) I used up most of two 1000 foot boxes.

    Don't pull single wires, pull bundles. When I had the holes drilled and the weather was cool enough to stay in the attic all day, I pulled the wire from both boxes through the house, along with the RG-6, then folded the end over and did it again twice. I used cheap box tape to hold the wires together in the interim, then I used cable ties to tie it together into one evil looking snake. It just barely fits in a 1" hole. So far I haven't crimped the ends of the RG-6, but when I do start using it, I'll just stuff the extra cat-5 keystone jack back into the wall.

    In two of the drops, I didn't have to drill because there was no drywall over the cabinets (nowadays the ceilings go in first, so I was lucky), and in another, there was already a hole where I wanted it. The last hole was the toughest because it was on an outside wall, the roof about three feet above me. I cut a hole for three-inch pipe in my closet, giving nine times the area of a 1" hole, just right for eight bundles and the outside wiring, then put a pipe and a right angle joint at the top. The hole was cut well enough that the whole thing fits snugly with no glue or plaster.

    Assorted bits of advice: Forget about fiber, it's too much of a pain in the arse for home use. The only fiber you want is one strand going out of your house (dream on!). And besides, there are two diameters, and single vs multi-mode, but cat-5 is cat-5. Don't forget about the RG-6, because that means you can have cable/satellite in any and every room in the house. And if you buy wood bits, get 1" bits, and get them made in the USA with lifetime warranty. Wal-Mart sells these for under three bucks each. The crap from China won't last for more than one or two holes. Ultrasonic stud finders kick ass. Wig pins are good for pushing through drywall to find out the exact point of a stud, both on walls and ceilings. Not all horizontal studs in your attic are directly over the wall; if you're not careful, you'll drill out the top of a wall or even worse, paneling. (Yes, I did drill out some paneling. That's how I know.)

    Switched 100mbit Ethernet in the kitchen kicks ass. And it means you get to use more AC circuits for those big LAN parties.

Get hold of portable property. -- Charles Dickens, "Great Expectations"

Working...