3Com Spinning Off US Robotics 74
DaveHowe writes, "According to the 3com press release they are spinning off their US Robotics modem line into a new company, shared jointly between them, Accton and NatSteel Electronics. It is also farming off its LAN router customers to Extreme Networks but will be keeping support for them as part of a "strategic alliance". " Hmmm...perhaps they had such a nice team with the PalmPilot IPO that they figure, hey why not do it with everything?
3Com going Open Source? (Score:1)
Is 3Com going open source? I don't think that this is good for the community because
3Com is used to monopoly power
All varieties of ethernet cards can be used under Linux, Free/OpenBSD. In fact, only NetBSD still sticks to the idea of a 3Com-only world.
The internet is making them obsolete. All 3Com is is a name. A brand name can be easily subverted online. Expect '4Com' or '2Com' to be created by Linux zealots.
Finally, it is a last-gasp effort. 3Com is going under and attempting to bring us with them. Why? I don't know. Revenge maybe?
All in all, I think that as a community, we must stand strong against 3Com's intrusions. We don't need them now anyway; our open source solutions are already superior.
Re:WTF... (Score:1)
ACK! (Score:1)
Compaq acquired DEC, not for it's Alpha or research labs, but for it's high-end know-how, and for it's world-class NT support team.
3com acquired USR, not for it's modems, but for Palm!!!
Therefore, it makes sense for 3com and Compaq to spin off (or sell) the unwanted portions of those business they acquired for their (to them, at least) tastier aspects.
Re:I used to have a modem (Score:1)
you're not funny anymore.
3COM & CISCO (Score:1)
What's left? (Score:1)
I never really saw 3Com as a big router company, either, but it's obviously big enough for them to spin off. What's left for 3Com to try to survive on besides selling overpriced NIC cards?
It's already been noted that they've pretty much shot themselves in the foot by spinning off Palm. It seems to me like they're going to be doing it again, twice.
Will the spun-off company be named "US Robotics"? (Score:1)
Re:I work for part of old USR - we are not spun! (Score:1)
Yes...
Arc - 4.2.32
DSP - 1.2.37 or 2.0.51
quad - 5.9.9 or 5.10.9
dual-pri - 3.0.2
nmc - 6.1.81
Working wonderfully here.
Jeff
Cycles (Score:1)
I wonder what the execs are making on these IPO deals.
Re:3Com: nothing but a name. (Score:1)
As for underpowered? The 3Com NICs, when they did work, did deliver speed, so I won't knock them on that account. But my Netgear cards are doing it as well.
BTW, I don't need a wake-on-LAN function as my servers are always awake (they run Linux). Besides, my LANs are way too active anyway.
Re:Thank GOD! (Score:1)
Not Surprised (Score:1)
--
Re:I work for part of old USR - we are not spun! (Score:1)
we are alive and well and will continue as part of 3Com
<shock>
Is this to say that you actually have OS and modem code that is acually stable for the TC?
</shock>
Re:Good for 3Com (Score:1)
Re:Good for 3Com (Score:1)
Re:Isn't USR a dead company? (Score:1)
The interesting question in a spinoff is to see just what assets are spun off, and what are kept. The old "USR" corporate boundaries are not likely to be respected.
Re:WTF... (Score:1)
You're wrong, though, about Agilent being what used to be the most profitable and successful part of the company. Ever bought a printer cartridge? 8^)
RE: Thank GOD (Score:1)
Microsoft = cisco = Old IBM
Old IBM = Buy it = you dont loos your job
It's not my kind of world
3Com Spin-Off Mania (Score:1)
Re:Not Surprised (Score:1)
Oh goodness, there was never any question that 3Com is just another one of the corporates, looking then and now to make a (reasonably) honest, if not ultimately moral, buck. OTOH, there is a project at linmodems.org [linmodems.org] to get open-source drivers for these devices and make them useful under Linux, if not as modems, then as telephony interfaces for a variety of useful tasks. Hopefully, the pressure on the vendors to release drivers for these devices will build as Linux grows in popularity.
Re:I work for part of old USR - we are not spun! (Score:1)
Re:What's left? (Score:1)
(FYI - I work for 3Com Carrier R&D)
I work for part of old USR - we are not spun! (Score:1)
Re:Isn't USR a dead company? (Score:1)
Modems can travel to wherever you have a phone line that isn't too noisy. Certainly, for my home system I'm using a faster connection. But when I'm travelling a laptop and a modem can still get me connected from virtually anywhere.
Reversing an Evolutionary Trend at 3Com (Score:1)
First there were the small, fast, agile little creatures like Palm and US Robotics. USR got a little bigger and swallowed up Palm. Then big 3Com swallowed up USR.
But it never got big enough to challenge the giants like Cisco while at the same time it was too big and clumsy to compete with smaller, more nimble little start ups. So they spun off Palm, letting it dart freely across the landscape the way it once did.
With one less mouth to feed, 3Com felt better and more limber than it had in years. So it looked around and decided to let USR roam free. After shedding the extra pounds, 3Com looked at itself in the mirror and liked what it saw.
Haven't we heard this story before? (Score:1)
Pan forward a few years.. the k56/X2 wars rage on and USR finds themselves losing even tho they're selling lots of product. Enter 3Com, who in one self ego-gratifying swoop consumes their rival. Ending the 56k wars, just in time for DSL (making THAT a fine investment.. not!). The interesting part here is the 'booby' prize that 3Com had aquired as part of USR... Palm Computing. Now Palm has been spun off, it's the new rich kid on the block, 3Com investors have more money, etc. But 3Com had no clue they had that diamond in USR's corporate coalheap, that's not what they're target was in buying USR. It was just luck. Glad someone at 3Com was paying attention, perhaps that can save them.
Now they're trying to farm off all of their modem equipment, which no one is buying much of anymore these days anyway in favor of ISDN/DSL/Cable Modems (at least not in the US - I can't speak for other countries). Hope they can succeed in trying to futher backpeddle on their USR expenditure.
all part of 3COM's housecleaning (Score:1)
Re:Good (Score:1)
SPVC336.EXE 3169558 09-28-97 Sportster Voice 33.6 Modem manual | (Self-extracting archive/MS Word format)
Try downloading that at 56K and extracting it - I would have spit nails if I had taken the time to do that. Luckily I have more bandwidth :)
Re:3Com: nothing but a name. (Score:1)
The company I work with has been using 3com NICs, Hubs, and Switches, and to be honest, you can't get anything better.
Just the NICs themselves are wonderfull. You mentioned the 3C-905tx,... this model has a wake-on-lan function which IMHO, is the best you can find.
Funny you should mention DEC Tulip based NICs. One of the contractors for my company brought in some HP servers which were equipped with such cards. One card fried, and started sending out high-voltage electricity across the ethernet cable. Least I say more?
It's all about the $$$ (Score:1)
If this is anything like the Palm IPO, 3Com's stock will drop a few dollars and they'll raise a fortune selling the USR stock. 3Com profits because they can keep controll of USR and selling it to investors as a different company, they can raise tons of money.
kwsNI
US Robotics (Score:1)
Speaking of which... RIP Hayes
Re:WTF... (Score:1)
Re:WTF... (Score:1)
Re:Highly unlikely. (Score:1)
Re:History Repeats itself (Score:1)
Re:Isn't USR a dead company? (Score:1)
There's nothing in the press release that screams "Innovative".
Re:"Improved personal productivity" is a lie (Score:1)
Who's to define what socialising means anymore? How can more and more people talking/E-mailing/SMS-ing etc possibly make people more distant from each other? Sure, there are still people who view the Internet as an end in itself... but the same is true of bars and coffee houses. If I want to be sociable, why should I have to conform to someone else's way of doing so?
(...OFF TOPIC!!)
Re:3Com: nothing but a name. (Score:1)
I expect another announcement in a couple weeks (Score:2)
Re:Good for 3Com (Score:2)
I'm
Re:Good for 3Com (Score:2)
Cable and DSL modems with USRobotics logo? (Score:2)
I think what is happening is that 3Com is reorganizing themselves to be ready when broadband Internet access becomes very common.
In fact, leveraging the well-known US Robotics brand, don't be surprised that a few years from now when you sign up for cable or ADSL broadband access, the ISP will provide you with a US Robotics-branded modem, either an external model that connects through an 10/100BaseT Ethernet NIC or USB port or an internal model that you install on the PCI port.
Re:3Com: nothing but a name. (Score:2)
They're overpriced and generally underpowered. In my own tests (ttcp, closed, switched network) their flagship 905tx was consistently slower than everything else, even realtek.
They do have a good warranty, but you're gonna need it. I've had many, many fail on me.
Personally my advice is this: If you want top performance in microsoft OSs, go for Intel 82559 based nics, for about half the price of 3Com. If you want top performance in Linux or BSD, go for a DEC Tulip or tulip-clone based nic like the Netgear FA-310TX for a quarter the price of 3Com. Genuine DEC 21140 Tulip cards are getting rare, most these days use a clone chip, you may have the best results with 2.2.14.
If you want cheap, various surplus vendors are carrying DEC 21140 Tulip based nics for about $12 each. You won't be disappointed. The ones I've seen are Samsung branded. Settling for less (Maxonix, Realtek) you will probably be disappointed. The Netgear nic can be had for $15.
So why blow $45 on a 3Com when it sucks? Screw the warranty, buy a spare for every machine for half the total cost.
WTF... (Score:2)
-mark
A new business model? (Score:2)
Palm Pilot was an awesome company, 3com just commoditized them and mediocered their innovation into the ground. Has anything really changed between the original Palm Pilot and the IIIc - ooh! it's in color! Look ma, same crappy basic apps, but in color!
I love my Palm Vx, but the innovation that is found in the Handspring (created by the original inventors of the palm pilot) is really indicitive of a stifling culture at 3com.
I wish US Robotics well, I'm sorry they had to suffer through 3com. Hopefully now they can return to innovating some kick ass products that geeks well lust after like the first time I saw a Courier 1200.
chris
Good for 3Com (Score:2)
It's a hoedown! (Score:2)
Buy'em up
Float'em for a while
When yer done
Spin them off
Watch them fall on the ground
YEEE HAW
When they're down
Pick'em up one more time
And do it all over again!!
---
Re:Good (Score:2)
Well, to be fair to them
however, from the other point of view -
--
Re:Good (Score:2)
You can usually get much better results if you go directly to the FTP site - try the following:
--
The cycle of life (Score:2)
U.S. Robotics is bought by 3Com
Palm Computing is sold by 3Com
U.S. Robotics is sold by 3Com
What's next?
Palm Computing is bought by U.S. Robotics?
Good (Score:2)
I haven't seen an update to their download section in months, so if one loses the "connections" cd, they are in for a hell of a time.
3Com: nothing but a name. (Score:2)
USR Courier Modems: excellent, but an acquisition
Palm Pilot: now spun off, and acquisition to boot
hubs: strictly me-too
switches: low end, me-too
routers: let's just say Cisco doesn't lose sleep
NOS: um, anyone even remember 3Com+share/open?
NICs: OK, these are pretty good. Basically, from its inception, 3Com has ridded the Etehrnet wave for all it is worth. Now that Etehrnet is now largely a commodity market, they are in trouble. Their last few acquisitions failed to revitilize the company and basically have to be spun back off to avoid destroying their value (unless you really believe that USR has fared well under 3Com's ownership, and that Palm is worse off on their own).
Look for good things from the new USR, but forget 3Com, they haven't shown any real direction of innovation for years.
How can modems compete...? (Score:2)
Easy. Unlike the lucky folks who live in larger populous centers, those of us in the north woods have no other options for internet connectivity from home, and we won't have them for a while yet. Heck, I can't even get a cable modem because the local cable company doesn't support them....and a lot of the folks up in The County don't even have cable to begin with, because their neighborhoods haven't been wired for it yet (population isn't dense enough to make it profitable). Dish Network et al. are big sellers up this way.
The modem market isn't going to dry up entirely until these more remote regions get more thoroughly wired. Will it decline? Of course... but there will be a niche for good old fashioned modems for several years to come.
-- WhiskeyJack, from the deepest, darkest wilds of Maine. ;)
Re:Isn't USR a dead company? (Score:2)
Someone has already pointed out that there are areas in the U.S. where there's nothing to choose but modem connection. But if you broaden your scope you will notice that many countries in the world still buy U.S.-made hardware. The internet is growing fast, and faster outside highly developed areas, where modems will be the only access route for many years to come.
This is already happening (I mean the repressed demand). When I run my BBS in '94, when I wanted to add a line I had a dozen places I could go to and buy a USR Sportster 14.400. Installing them was a breeze. Today I cannot find a Sportster to replace the crappy WinModem that came with what is now my Linux box (I live in a small town without ISDN, in Brazil). I had to "steal" the USR 28.8k card from the box my children use. And many others don't "turn" to Linux because of this.
Read Elsewhere (Score:3)
One can poke fun at the business model (buy a company, then spin it off), but it was just bad timing by 3Com. They picked up USR when it was at the top of the peak and now they're letting it go. It's good they recognize the harm in keeping it, because that will maybe allow them to survive. Same goes with Palm, because managing Palm took resources away from other areas they need to concentrate on. I wouldn't be surprised if they created another company or completely separate subdivision to manage their home product line either (cards, small hubs, etc.) as that market's growth is slowing down, too (supposedly, I'm no expert; just reporting what I remember reading).
With the way that Internet business world is shaping up, though, who can tell what will happen?
Re:History Repeats itself (Score:3)
You know, i couldn't resist, sure 'nuf, it's a site...aoltimewarner.com [aoltimewarner.com] Coming soon... The World's First Media and Communications Company for the Internet Age
Gotta love it
Highly unlikely. (Score:3)
The idea of 3Com having monopoly power is, frankly, laughable. If there is a monopoly in the world of netwrecking, it is held by Cisco and their high-end routers (although I'm not trying to sling mud here; merely stating the obvious).
The atmosphere here today in the UK is *weird*, though; there's metaphorical blood all over the walls, as they appear to be trying to get rid of the entire customer support department - their strategy appears to be to make everything so point-and-drool that even a moron can operate it and use this as an excuse not to have anything more than a vestigial customer support service.
In other news: (Score:3)
What we really have to watch out for is when Microsoft decides to spin off all the companies *they've* acquired--with all those companies spinning merrily away someone could lose an eye.
--
3Com a has been--already? (Score:3)
I wouldn't count them out, though. CEO Eric Benhamou is a very smart guy and if 3Com is shedding some extra weight, they must also have something good planned ahead. Too bad for 3Com that they bought U.S. Robotics right as the market for analog modems peaked out at 56K. Palm was really the only feather in their cap, and they did the honorable thing to let it go before their own decline affected it.
As a side note, a Dell computer I just bought has its official "3Com 56K" modem listed as a U.S. Robotics modem. Go figure.
--
History Repeats itself (Score:3)
Clarifications (Score:4)
Extreme is getting 3Com's CoreBuilder line...this is very high end routers and switches.
Motorola is get most of the PathBuilder and most of the NetBuilder lines (3Com will retain a few of the products in each of these lines). NetBuilders are the more traditional routers, PathBuilders are workgroup and specialty switches.
NatSteel and Accton (sp?) get the modems, NetSteel also gets the manufacturing facility in the Chicago suburbs (nice facility...toured it in October) and will manufacture 3Com equipment under contract there. This facility manufactures all of the Total Control line of equipment I believe, as well as cable modems, and DSL modems (3Com only does CPE DSL modems at this point). I believe they also do whatever the Sportster line is called now at that facility, and probably a couple of other things I'm forgetting.
The modems will be spun off into their own company called "USRobotics" (what goes around comes around) in conjunction with NatSteel and Accton. Its important to note that the purchase of USRobotics approximately 3 years ago included Palm, and the Total Control line...Palm, of course, is already spun off, and Total Control is being retained by 3Com, so this really isn't the same USRobotics from days or yore. Personally, I tend to think its better...more focused...USRobotics had trouble executing on the Total Control back then (we used the line back then even), focusing on only consumer analog modems may allow them to return to the quality of USRobotics modems that many of us remember from years gone by. I hope.
So...now the question that a lot of people ask when they hear all this..."What does that leave?"
Well...as I mentioned...Total Control, which is really a whole line of products and is aimed at Carriers and ISPs, is still gonna be there. I suspect the part of the PathBuilder line that they are keeping as well is being held on to in order to complement the Total Control.
This also leaves home networking and small business networking (nics, ISDN routers, small hubs, etc.), I also suspect the part of the NetBuilder line that they are retaining will be there to complement this part of the business...the low end of the NetBuilders.
The last part that is still there is the VOIP product lines and related products. The NBX 100 and 3Com's ethernet phones are supposed to be pretty nifty...though I haven't had a chance to try any out yet. A couple of the acquisitions that were announced were to beef up this area...unified messaging, etc.
As a 3Com customer...particularly of the Total Control line...I see all of this as a very good thing. I do find it interesting though. When I think of what 3Com is...I think of NetBuilder and CoreBuilder...its almost like 3Com is selling off their identity and becoming a totally new company in the process. The new logo almost confirms this idea (note I'm *definitely* in the realm of my own personal opinion here, take it for what you will).
I've always thought the Total Control line was the "ugly step-child" of 3Com...and now they seem like they want to make that the core of their business...I say more power to them!
Any way you look at it, there are interesting days ahead.
Jeff
Isn't USR a dead company? (Score:4)
It sounds to me like 3Com sees this (if they can't then they are pretty bloody stupid) and is now letting them float out there for someone to buy in the next few years.